Colin Houlson RSS Feed


Let's erect a statue to Margaret Haywood, Angel of the Southeast

Photograph of the Author By Colin Houlson - Life, Hove and everything »

Are you familiar with the song Kick Over The Statues? Far be it from me to criticise the Redskins' 1985 agitpop anthem, but I don't feel the band really thought the idea through. The Statue Of Liberty weighs in at more than 200 metric tonnes. At that weight, even the gigantic monster in the film Cloverfield must have needed a good run-up before he managed to boot her head across downtown Manhattan. And here in Brighton, although the statue of comedian Max Miller is far more modestly constructed than Lady Liberty, you'd still need feet like Kate Winslet (size 11, celeb fact fans) to even make a dent in it.

No, I think a different approach is required. I'm not suggesting someone should write a song called Erect Statues - let's face it, with a title like that it wouldn't get much daytime airplay - but I believe more public figures should be celebrated in sculptures. Brighton already has a fine track record when it comes to honouring achievement. Over the years, dozens of buses have borne the names of famous people with a connection to the city, ranging from film legend Lord Attenborough to footballer Bobby Zamora. When boarding Virginia Woolf, more than one smart-aleck Sussex University student must have been tempted to ask: 'How much is it to the lighthouse?' Great thinkers have also debated whether allocating left-wing activist Eleanor Marx the number 666 was a case of political demonisation. Personally, I like to imagine that the bus named after The Who was fittingly smashed up into to little pieces when it was withdrawn from service.

With this tradition firmly established, a subject has to be found for the first statue. Like Lady Liberty, I want to commemorate a person who's been a torch carrier for truth and justice. Someone who wasn't afraid to shine a light into the dark corners of society. So step forward, Margaret Haywood, who's been removed from the register of nurses for secretly filming at Brighton's Royal Sussex County Hospital. Appalled by conditions in the hospital's Peel & Stewart acute medical ward, but finding that complaints to her bosses fell on deaf ears, Ms Haywood - a nurse for 20 years - used a secret camera to capture the neglect of elderly patients. The details of what she filmed are horrifying and have been well documented elsewhere, so I won't repeat them here. Suffice it to say, after the footage was shown on BBC1's Panorama programme in 2005, Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust issued a public apology admitting 'serious lapses in the quality of care' and questions were asked in Parliament. Last week, Ms Haywood was struck off because it's said she failed to 'follow her obligations as a nurse'. It's incredible that, despite a story like this being presented on a programme called Panorama, certain people still can't see the bigger picture.

Now I have a deserving subject, as I'm sure you'll agree, only two questions remain... Firstly, what will the statue be called? Well, Gateshead has its Angel Of The North and, since nurses have often been described using celestial terms, naming it Angel Of The Southeast seems very apt. And finally, where will it stand? The perfect location would be Brighton & Hove Albion's new stadium, which is due to open its doors in 2011. This would give the city a chance to make history. After all, there can't be another football ground in the world that's ever celebrated a whistleblower.


Comments(13)

molesecrets says...
8:03pm Mon 27 Apr 09

Pity Mr Houlson hasn't checked his facts. Margaret Haywood was struck off the nursing register not for whistleblowing but for breaching patient confidentiality as she didn't gain their consent when filming. How many of us would honestly feel it was okay for our elderly mums and dads to be filmed whilst they were suffering and the results then broadcast to millions on TV? Rather than help those who she was supposed to be caring for immediately, this nurse carried on filming and didn't report her concerns to help patients when they needed it. The point which keeps getting overlooked is that Margaret Haywood didn't do anything immediately to help those who were suffering. She wasnt a nurse who had tried and was ignored and so contacted the BBC. She was employed by the BBC to go into the hospital to film which is very different. Nobody can condone the appalling conditions captured on film but the point is a real nurse would have helped patients then and there - not carried on filming over a period of months for the BBC.

monstersharky says...
9:34pm Mon 27 Apr 09

This doesn't recognise the fact that this nurse fround appaling conditions! Any real nurse should be not only horrified by what she found BUT should also acknowledge that the NMC is nothing but a mouthpiece for hospital managers! It does not serve the public or the profession as a whole but seeks ot represent only those in charge! Managers are the infection currently afflicting the NHS - the sooner they are put against a wall, the better!

Tye says...
8:08am Tue 28 Apr 09

molesecrets wrote:
Pity Mr Houlson hasn't checked his facts. Margaret Haywood was struck off the nursing register not for whistleblowing but for breaching patient confidentiality as she didn't gain their consent when filming. How many of us would honestly feel it was okay for our elderly mums and dads to be filmed whilst they were suffering and the results then broadcast to millions on TV? Rather than help those who she was supposed to be caring for immediately, this nurse carried on filming and didn't report her concerns to help patients when they needed it. The point which keeps getting overlooked is that Margaret Haywood didn't do anything immediately to help those who were suffering. She wasnt a nurse who had tried and was ignored and so contacted the BBC. She was employed by the BBC to go into the hospital to film which is very different. Nobody can condone the appalling conditions captured on film but the point is a real nurse would have helped patients then and there - not carried on filming over a period of months for the BBC.
There speaks an idiot or someone whose raking it in for doing a cr4p job I suggest- loads of league tables and a gold plated pension eh?.

Personally I cannot forgive you your views - may your "god" (mammon?) forgive you and hope that you are never in such a hospital

This poor woman had reported the dreadful conditions several times and NOTHING happened.

the BBC also got the OK from either ALL the people involved or from their families.

It was only after the "whistle blowing" and the bad publicity in the papers and on Television that anything happened - IF she had done nothing appart from using the "internal complaints procedure" NOTHING would have got resolved

King from Hove says...
9:11am Tue 28 Apr 09

They have all since agreed.Mole secrets we are not interested in your so biased views.Well done Margaret.

bill67 says...
10:15am Tue 28 Apr 09

I saw panorama last night. Its the people at the top who need to be struck off. The way they have treated Margaret has done nothing to improve my faith in the integrity of some of the protectionist culture that appears to be pervasive within NHS management. What Margaret did achieved results for the people that matter. How many more patients would have endured such appalling neglect otherwise?

Txa says...
6:05pm Tue 28 Apr 09

What we really, really would like to know if any real changes has been taking place at the hospital to reassure us that the appalling treatment of patients won't happened again in the future. And to reinstate Margaret job would be a start.

Then a plaque could be located at the entrance of the Hospital, to remind the medical staff their obligation of proper care towards their patients, to remind patients to respect and trust the medical staff during their care. And to remind us all how Margaret courageously stood up on the patients side to receive the dignify care that patients deserve.


km69 says...
6:15pm Tue 28 Apr 09

Perhaps, in due course a statue or perhaps a plaque reading “Margaret (Margie) Haywood, Health Care Reformer” attached to her past residence, while staying herein Brighton, would be appropriate recognition: in the meantime, how about a Care-way Code, “Margaret’s code for carers (of the elderly)” – something that would help to prevent unnecessary suffering and deaths?
Margaret Haywood: a modern Florence Nightingale in that, like in the Crimean where too many soldiers suffered and died due to lack of care, Margaret has made us all aware that today too many of the elderly in Britain suffer and/or die early due to the lack of care for their well-being. Reference: Margaret’s past undercover-filming at the Royal Sussex Hospital, Brighton; and more recently, the mortality-rates at the Stafford Hospital, Mid-Staffordshire.
When considering Margaret’s letter to her family for when she becomes elderly and needs looking-after, perhaps, with her permission, it can become something that could have national significance? Please consider the possibility of forming a “Care-way Code”, perhaps, a “Margaret Haywood code for carers of the elderly” from her list-of-points itemised in her letter to her family. Please consider it and perhaps the Argus (our local paper) might like to champion such a code – try and get it some national significance!
I feel that without some nationally recognised basic code/list of good practice for the carers to aspire to then the problem of poor care for the elderly will continue, with future Chief Executives of Trusts writing apologetic letters while persecuting the whistleblowers – it seems to me that it’s the guilty that are excused while the good-intentioned are penalised – how can Margaret lose her job when doing something that is overridingly good and well-intentioned. Similarly, how can any chairperson of a governing body (e.g. the Nursing and Midwifery Council) not find someway to delay and avoid the case against Margaret from coming on the agenda and being discussed and assessed in the all too predictable perfunctory committee-way with the inevitable punitive consequences to Margaret’s livelihood a foregone conclusion to those in the know – And, given the unbending Nursing and Midwifery code, a code-of-practice that needs to be seen to be defended by its guardians – how can the N.M.C. now overturn their decision at appeal? I don’t know, but I hope they do! I urge them to find a way! Perhaps, if they can’t the government’s overriding 2006 Whistleblower legislation (Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998) needs to step-in and help the well-intentioned Margaret regain her nursing status and livelihood?
In the BBC Panorama programme, Who’d be an NHS Whistleblower? Margie said, “What does basic nursing care cost?” Well, when you hear her list you do know, what ever it does cost it should not be something that standards of care fall below – hence the idea of a Code for Carers of the Elderly.
K. M.
Brighton Resident



Tye says...
8:03am Fri 1 May 09

Perhaps the NMC should be investigated?

defending the indefencible should not be funded by the tax payer

crownjewel says...
1:55pm Fri 1 May 09

My questions is:
What changes have been made in this hospital since the well needed expose of shameful nursing, medical, cleaning and managerial care of these patients?
Well done Margaret for having the courage to DO SOMETHING to (hopefully) make a change for the better. It is more than can be said for the management team who failed in their responsibilities at every level.

Colin Houlson says...
1:34pm Sat 2 May 09

Molesecrets, thanks for your response. I can assure you that all the facts have been checked. As other readers have noted, Margaret Haywood made repeated efforts to bring these issues to the attention of her bosses. It wasn't within her power to effect change on her own, which is why she turned to the media. We should all be grateful that she did.

chalcot says...
8:18pm Sun 3 May 09

We should be saluting her: she knew she was risking her job but also knew it was the only way to get anything changed. It's appalling that she was scapegoated.

green-griffin says...
3:52pm Mon 4 May 09

she done a good deed. well done. but not greatly worth a statue because not alot of improvement came to the hospital anyway other than a clean.

Emma Cave says...
4:06pm Mon 4 May 09

It takes a lot of guts for a person to blow the whistle once. How she found the nerve to do it repeatedly staggers me. Filming what was going on must have taken even more courage. A statue it should be!

HEROINE: Margaret Haywood HEROINE: Margaret Haywood

Our Bloggers


Recent entries

May 2012 »
S M T W T F S
29 30 01 02 03 04 05
06 07 08 09 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 01 02

RSS