Brighton and Hove businesses welcome parking charge U-turn (From The Argus)
Get involved: Send your news, views, pictures and video by texting SUPIC to 80360 or email us.
Brighton and Hove businesses welcome parking charge U-turn
1:10pm Tuesday 8th January 2013 in News By Tim Ridgway, Local government reporter
Buy this photo »
Campaigners Max Leviston from Brighton Sea Life Centre and Laura Sackett celebrate the news
Parking tariffs are to be frozen and even reduced in the wake of public pressure to Park The Charges.
In a victory for people power, Brighton and Hove City Council has announced there will be no increases to the majority of its on and off-street parking rates from April.
In the face of mass criticism of last year’s rises, tariffs in the most controversial areas, such as the seafront and London Road, will be reduced.
But while businesses will gain from the relaxing of the rates, residents will be forced to pay more for permits to mitigate the cuts.
Driven away
Businesses, residents and visitors have all claimed the Green administration’s decision to charge up to £20 a day has driven people away.
While partly blaming the wet weather and the economic situation, transport bosses now admit there has been a drop in parking numbers of up to 60% in some areas.
This has created a £200,000 black hole in the council’s budget.
However, officials have refused to revert back to 2011/12 prices claiming it would not meet their aim to reduce congestion and push people towards more sustainable forms of transport.
Lost business
Ann Townsend, who has campaigned against the charges in London Road, said: “It has been a disaster.
“If the council has lost out on £200,000, how much has been lost to businesses?
“It is good to see public pressure has worked.”
Under proposals to be discussed by councillors next week, on street pay and display charges will be frozen in 2013/14 – a reduction in real terms when inflation is taken into account.
Prices will also be reduced in London Road and the seafront areas.
Parking permits
However, the cost of 22,500 resident parking permits will be increased to partly cover the concession.
Charges at Trafalgar Street and Regency Square car park, which will be renamed Brighton Centre, will be increased following worth more than £4 million of work.
Business and trader permits will be halved for low emission vehicles.
But appeals to reintroduce 30 minute tariffs and give free parking in Norton Road in Hove at weekends have been ignored for being too costly.
It marks a change of policy for the Green administration which raised city centre prices to £3.50 an hour and up to £20 a day on the seafront 12 months ago.
'Tackle congestion'
In a statement, transport committee chairman Ian Davey claimed the new plans were “positive”, adding: “These proposals help meet the needs of residents and tourists while maintaining vital work to tackle congestion and reduce air pollution in the city centre.
“These plans will also compliment our excellent public transport system that provides for residents and the growing number of visitors to the city.”
Max Leviston, of Madeira Drive Traders’ Association, said: “I’m certain it will help.
“£15 for a day is at the top end of parking charges, but when you look at NCP car parks both in the city and elsewhere I think they have got it right.”
'Excessive charges'
Nick Head, of Brighton and Hove Hoteliers’ Association, said: “The news could be better but it is extremely welcome.
“We have all lost a lot of business due to the excessive charges.”
Conservative councillor Graham Cox said: “It would be churlish not to welcome this change of heart by the Greens.
“However, we feel that many charges are still too high.”
Labour councillor Gill Mitchell said: “The Greens’ parking strategy is clearly not working - they are not listening to residents or councillors who are calling for a more sensible fee structure. Their whole parking policy is in chaos.”
Planned Parking Charges
Madeira Drive and the seafront (summer)
One hour £3 (was £3.50)
Two hours £5 (was £6)
Eight hours scrapped (was £15)
11 hours £15 (was £20)
Summer season, which was April to September, now March to October (inclusive).
New Steine, Cheapside and The Level on-street
1 hour £2 (was £3.50)
2 hours £4 (was £6)
4 hours £6 (was £10)
Resident parking permits
1 year (full scheme) £120 (was £115)
1 year (light touch) £90 (was £80)
Visitor permits
Full scheme (per permit) £2.60 (was £2.50)
Light touch (per permit) £1.60 (was £1.50)
Traders permits
One year £600 (no change)
3 months £160 (no change)
One year - low emission £300 (down from £600)
3 months - low emission £80 (down from £160)
Business permits
One year £300 (no change)
3 months £85 (no change)
One year - low emission £150 (down from £300)
3 months - low emission £42.50 (down from £85)
Argus Comment
When the new parking charges were introduced in April 2012, the Green-led city council believed they would reduce congestion and push people towards more sustainable forms of transport.
They would also raise an additional £1.3 million towards its budget.
Has it been a success?
Overall, the local authority says there have been 3% fewer transactions than planned for, resulting in a £200,000 budget black hole.
Official figures produced show that every month from April to October saw a reduction in paid-for hours across the city.
Falling numbers
April saw the biggest drop – a reduction from 815,000 hours in 2011 to 672,000 in 2012.
Only August had comparable numbers, with use reducing from 852,000 to 851,000.
In addition, the local authority said parking transactions in Madeira Drive, where parking costs up to £20 a day during the summer, have reduced by 22%.
In the same period, visits to London Road decreased by 10% yet stays in its off-street car park, where favourable rates are offered, increased by 20%.
In comparison, there was a 5% increase in journeys on Brighton and Hove buses in the last year.
The council also claims trips made on foot and by bike are also generally increasing although there are no official figures to support this.
See the latest news headlines from The Argus:
- Police release pictures of brothers wanted in connection with Hove shooting
- Albion sex trial jury sent out to consider verdict
- Visually-impaired man set on fire in Brighton street
- Brighton chiropractor could save thousands from going under the knife
- Tweets and posts inspire graffiti wall
Add us to your circles on Google+
Comments(54)
mrs m ward
says...
1:26pm Tue 8 Jan 13
pay its wages,not dictate to them.
Phani Tikkala
says...
1:33pm Tue 8 Jan 13
The green policy is to reduce the number of cars coming into the city centre/seafront, no matter what cost to local businesses.
Political suicide.
s&k
says...
1:49pm Tue 8 Jan 13
s&k
says...
1:49pm Tue 8 Jan 13
DC Brighton
says...
2:02pm Tue 8 Jan 13
If local businesses think reducing parking charges will help them then this should be something they are gambling some of their money on, not me.
Furthermore, if the scheme is successful then the "black hole" of £200k (it is a black hole only because the council got its predictions wrong) should be filled by the additional hours spent parking at the cheaper rate, not by charging Brighton residents another £5 to park outside their houses. Well, it would if any kind of analysis had taken place, which seems very unlikely given the proposal.
This really is very simple supply and demand.
I shall spend £5 less on buses this year then which won't be difficult - that's one return trip these days.
thevoiceoftruth
says...
2:07pm Tue 8 Jan 13
s&k wrote:I wouldn't go that far. From what I could see they were sticking their fingers in their ears singing 'tra la la'. However, money talks and this catastrophic idea has lost them £200,000. Well done the council *slow hand clap*.
The Council have listened. That's a good thing and all credit to them for that.
Kate234
says...
2:42pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Jimmy Stewart's Imaginary Rabbit
says...
2:48pm Tue 8 Jan 13
MegA69
says...
2:51pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Hoarder12345444
says...
3:06pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Mark63
says...
3:09pm Tue 8 Jan 13
ThinkBrighton
says...
3:14pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Vote them out
Fight_Back
says...
3:18pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Let's now examine their new idea of increasing significantly charges for sports facilities. Hmmmm ...... I wonder what's going to happen ....... ah yes ..... another blackhole and U turn.
Really, are Kitcat and his merry dunces REALLY this thick ?
gbfroggy
says...
4:12pm Tue 8 Jan 13
The council has increased the price of parking to discourage people from coming by car....
It should therefore be very pleased of itself for the drop of people coming by car.....
However it changes its angle when it comes to money....we don't talk of victory but of a shorfall of earnings...
So who pays...the local people...absolute nonsense!!!
Dear council you can't have the cake and eat it. What do you want exactly, a reduction of traffic or a cash cow...
Hoarder12345444
says...
4:14pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Mark63 wrote:Yeah its like churchill square, that is an absolute rip off that car park, the company that runs it must make an absolute fortune.
Good to see that there are some reductions, but the Lanes Car Park wanted me to pay £4 an hour last weekend, so I drove straight back out - its a criminal tax on visitors and locals alike - no wonder people are turning away in their droves - they won't be back either. I've stopped using the City Centre because of the appalling charges - other places are far more welcoming and much easier and cheaper to park in... Thanks Greens - still ruining Brighton and Hove!
BornInBrighton1968
says...
5:02pm Tue 8 Jan 13
If we all work together, we can remove the Greens from power in a matter of months!
xc90chris
says...
5:11pm Tue 8 Jan 13
ton-hove.gov.uk/mgEP
etitionDisplay.aspx?
Id=360 - have you all signed it?
just-a-person
says...
5:27pm Tue 8 Jan 13
xc90chris wrote:No I had not heard of this. Thanks for sharing and I will be signing right now.
A number of comments about voting the greens out, there is actually a petition currently running on the council's website at http://present.brigh
ton-hove.gov.uk/mgEP
etitionDisplay.aspx?
Id=360 - have you all signed it?
just-a-person
says...
5:33pm Tue 8 Jan 13
NickBrt
says...
5:53pm Tue 8 Jan 13
george smith
says...
6:12pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Joe Average
says...
6:14pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Money to the Council for parking or spent with local traders? Nuff said.
fredaj
says...
6:19pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Kate234 wrote:Slagging people off because of their name is about as childish as it gets and out of interest, Kitcat is Jason's real name.
The Green party should hold their head in shame at this news and the £200,000 shortfall should be deducted from their salaries to give them a taste of what this policy has cost ordinary people in the city. The parking increases have been catastrophic for businesses in the City and this reckless decision has cost jobs and I am sure many people their living. The cost to businesses has been immense and will take years after the Green party gets thrown out to recover. People don't just come back overnight. The city is being run by a someone that has changed his name to that of a chocolate bar and we are paying for this big time. Lets get rid of the greens and have no more Caroline Fish Fingers, Ian Cornflakes or any other ridiculous Green politicians in the town again. I'm sure no other party could possibly do a worst job.
It's an old English one I believe.
fredaj
says...
6:22pm Tue 8 Jan 13
BornInBrighton1968 wrote:If "hard working tax payers" had got off their bums and voted last time, the Greens would not have got it.
Now is the time for all Brighton men and women of good charachter to stand up and say "Let's get the Greens out of Brighton!". Just because they we voted in by students (who thought that they were being trendy and alternative by voting Green, but still fly-tip at the end of term when they dump their rubbish to go home to mummy and daddy) doesn't mean that hard-working council tax payers have to put up with he Greens.
If we all work together, we can remove the Greens from power in a matter of months!
Perhaps just proves that people not only get the politicians they vote for, but also the ones they deserve.
Ballroom Blitz
says...
7:28pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Ballroom Blitz
says...
7:34pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Unconnected to the ludicrously high parking charges? I don't think so. Customers complain on a daily basis.
Maxwell's Ghost
says...
8:05pm Tue 8 Jan 13
It purely changed the destination of motorists.....also local radio was advertising some astonishingly cheap Christmas shopping trips by rail to London.
Dealing with idiots
says...
8:14pm Tue 8 Jan 13
just-a-person wrote:Ms Lucas has a Landrover.
I would like to know if any of the Green Party members own a car ? Anyone know ? Pictures would be great.
Ballroom Blitz
says...
8:21pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Maxwell's Ghost wrote:Exactly Maxwell. Why go to Brighton, with its mental parking charges, when you can go to a similar massive shopping mall in Crawley, where I think they had NO parking charges on the Sunday before Xmas! And their charges are half the Churchill Square prices even on normal days.
Only the naive would think that putting parking parking prices up would change behaviour.
It purely changed the destination of motorists.....also local radio was advertising some astonishingly cheap Christmas shopping trips by rail to London.
Idontbelieveit1948
says...
8:28pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Ballroom Blitz wrote:Couldn't agree more. This is hardly a victory, merely a slight reduction which still leaves parking charges hiked by many times inflation.
Hardly a u turn. More like a 10 degree turn. Too little, too late.
A victory would be returnng to March 2012 charges, prior to the hike, and then retuning to adding inflationary charges each April.
This little gesture will make no difference.
just-a-person
says...
8:41pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Dealing with idiots wrote:"Caroline is the MP for Brighton Pavilion. She served as Leader of the Green Party of England & Wales from 2008 to 2012.
just-a-person wrote:Ms Lucas has a Landrover.
I would like to know if any of the Green Party members own a car ? Anyone know ? Pictures would be great.
A passionate campaigner on the environment, social justice and human rights, Caroline was voted the UK's Most Ethical Politician in 2007, 2009 and 2010 by Observer readers, and is one of the Environment Agency's Top 100 Eco-Heroes.
Caroline lives in Brighton with her husband and two sons."
I just read that on her website. A passionate campaigner on the environment but drives a Landrover !!! Brilliant.
Idontbelieveit1948
says...
8:51pm Tue 8 Jan 13
just-a-person wrote:Not only a Landrover but also five homes - all very enviromentaly friendly I hope !
Dealing with idiots wrote:"Caroline is the MP for Brighton Pavilion. She served as Leader of the Green Party of England & Wales from 2008 to 2012.
just-a-person wrote:Ms Lucas has a Landrover.
I would like to know if any of the Green Party members own a car ? Anyone know ? Pictures would be great.
A passionate campaigner on the environment, social justice and human rights, Caroline was voted the UK's Most Ethical Politician in 2007, 2009 and 2010 by Observer readers, and is one of the Environment Agency's Top 100 Eco-Heroes.
Caroline lives in Brighton with her husband and two sons."
I just read that on her website. A passionate campaigner on the environment but drives a Landrover !!! Brilliant.
Hoarder12345444
says...
8:52pm Tue 8 Jan 13
just-a-person wrote:she lives in Belgium I thought
Dealing with idiots wrote:"Caroline is the MP for Brighton Pavilion. She served as Leader of the Green Party of England & Wales from 2008 to 2012.
just-a-person wrote:Ms Lucas has a Landrover.
I would like to know if any of the Green Party members own a car ? Anyone know ? Pictures would be great.
A passionate campaigner on the environment, social justice and human rights, Caroline was voted the UK's Most Ethical Politician in 2007, 2009 and 2010 by Observer readers, and is one of the Environment Agency's Top 100 Eco-Heroes.
Caroline lives in Brighton with her husband and two sons."
I just read that on her website. A passionate campaigner on the environment but drives a Landrover !!! Brilliant.
Maxwell's Ghost
says...
8:52pm Tue 8 Jan 13
I had a number of meetings all over Sussex and a busy diary so had to use my car. It cost me £10 to park in the car park which shocked me and the person I was meeting who was from outside the city.
The only positive was the car park was surprisingly empty.
All future meetings have been scheduled for hotels at Gatwick. Free parking, rail and car connections.
Grumpy0ldman
says...
9:35pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Over the hill and far away
says...
9:37pm Tue 8 Jan 13
Weirdorama
says...
10:59pm Tue 8 Jan 13
funkyyoyo
says...
12:24am Wed 9 Jan 13
ha
Kate234
says...
4:24am Wed 9 Jan 13
BornInBrighton1968
says...
6:38am Wed 9 Jan 13
george smith wrote:Helping to build 'Brussels' Lucas's UFO research centre?
Where is H Jarrs?
xc90chris
says...
8:16am Wed 9 Jan 13
http://present.brigh
ton-hove.gov.uk/mgEP
etitionDisplay.aspx?
Id=360 -
have you all signed it?
Jimmy Stewart's Imaginary Rabbit
says...
8:17am Wed 9 Jan 13
Jimmy Stewart's Imaginary Rabbit
says...
8:19am Wed 9 Jan 13
Dealing with idiots
says...
8:59am Wed 9 Jan 13
Jimmy Stewart's Imaginary Rabbit wrote:Seen driving away in one after speaking to students at Basvic late last year. .
I'm sorry, I do not believe that Caroline Lucas possesses a Landrover. I think that's just a scurrilous rumour as even by the standards of politicians that. would be breathtaking hypocrisy. She's not THAT bad.
Dealing with idiots
says...
9:01am Wed 9 Jan 13
Dealing with idiots
says...
9:11am Wed 9 Jan 13
funkyyoyo wrote:That was a rather delicious moment. Did any one capture that for Youtube?
does this black hole amount of money include the £30 repainting cost to all the unenforcable illegal parking bays in brighton,which guess whos paying for?? nice to see ian worral the council parking grovellor on bbc 1 last night 'parking mad' never mind the guy saying the sign was missing,it wasnt the statuory distance from the start of the 'lane' as none of them are hahahahahahahahahaha ha
MegA69
says...
9:12am Wed 9 Jan 13
Fairfax Sakes
says...
9:32am Wed 9 Jan 13
Phani Tikkala
says...
10:12am Wed 9 Jan 13
Hoarder12345444
says...
12:31pm Wed 9 Jan 13
Fairfax Sakes wrote:You what? What is this middle class Toff drivel you speak of. Silly person.
I think the Greens have rather done Brighton a favour: by reducing the swarms of Londoners and other undesirable rabble, we are at least moving to a more exclusive clientele the city deserves. For those of us who can afford it, what does an extra few quid matter anyway. As for the sea side 'traders' selling tat and deep fried foods, better off well rid I should say.
Jimmy Stewart's Imaginary Rabbit
says...
2:52pm Wed 9 Jan 13
Fairfax Sakes wrote:Agreed. Close down all those awful fast food places and chain stores and have all the shops as nice little boutiques selling handmade pashmina clothes and organic tofu. And when they've got all the poor people off the streets perhaps they'll make the parking spaces a bit bigger? After all we won't need so many and because of its size Jeeves does struggle to park the Rolls sometimes. These Green chaps aren't that bad at all really are they what what?
I think the Greens have rather done Brighton a favour: by reducing the swarms of Londoners and other undesirable rabble, we are at least moving to a more exclusive clientele the city deserves. For those of us who can afford it, what does an extra few quid matter anyway. As for the sea side 'traders' selling tat and deep fried foods, better off well rid I should say.
MaryBale
says...
4:25pm Wed 9 Jan 13
MuammarQaddafi
says...
10:15am Thu 10 Jan 13
Mr_Tom says...
1:19pm Tue 8 Jan 13