News RSS Feed


New-look gateways to the city

10:13am Wednesday 25th July 2007

comment Comments (27)   Have your say »


A radical overhaul of three downtrodden and deprived districts has been revealed.

A city business quarter, a cultural centre in St Peter's Church and a public square at the Vogue Gyratory are just three recommendations to inject life into Brighton's London Road, Lewes Road and Preston Road areas.

Two reports outline essential changes to the roads and paint an image of neglect and subtle decay in contrast to the "upbeat and modern image" of the area.

Brighton and Hove City Council plans to transform Lewes Road into an academic corridor including:

  • A public square at the Vogue Gyratory.
  • Grants for shopfronts and a ban on fast food outlets.
  • Moving Moulsecoomb station southwards to cater for the new Preston Barracks redevelopment, which will include hundreds of new homes.
  • A tree-lined Lewes Road and improvements to Saunders Park.

The report says transforming the traffic-choked gyratory, where Lewes Road, Upper Lewes Road, Bear Road and Hollingdean Road meet, is crucial.

Sainsbury's and the petrol station should be knocked down, the report suggests, and redeveloped.

The consultants advise: "Remodelling the Vogue Gyratory and with it redeveloping adjacent sites has the potential to transform the Lewes Road corridor, to eliminate an area of very poor urban quality and pedestrian environment and to provide a better link between the high street section of Lewes Road to the south and the broader, dual carriageway section to the north.

"Until substantial remodelling takes place, the Vogue will continue to blight the image, built and pedestrian environments and economic vitality of the Lewes Road corridor."

London Road could become the new cultural and business centre of the city, the report suggests. Proposals include:

  • A "mini City of London" in the New England Quarter with tall buildings.
  • New 20mph roads.
  • St Peter's Church transformed into art studios and a cultural centre.
  • A one-way, bus-only London Road.
  • The Open Market modelled on Borough Market, Southwark, London.
  • Restoration and improvements to shop facades.
  • Improvements to the run-down car park to the west of London Road and the possible creation of another to the east.
  • A green boulevard leading from The Level to the seafront, cutting the fourlane carriageway to the west down to a bus lane and moving all other traffic to the east.

Tony Mernagh, the head of Brighton and Hove Business Forum, said a new business quarter had the potential to transform London Road.

He said: "There is nothing better than putting lots of people into an area which will then respond to their needs.We really need to get as much as possible out of that space."

The report reads: "St Peter's Church has the potential to become the lynch pin for the cultural quarter. As such, any future uses of it should look to strengthen and exemplify the concept and link between the cultural quarter and the commercial quarter.

The report also calls for the council to help bring the long-derelict Astoria building back into use.

Preston Road is criticised by the consultants for its un-let, run-down and inappropriate commercial buildings.

Recommendations include:

  • Intensifying development between South Road and Dyke Road Drive, bringing buildings closer to the road.
  • Transforming the viaduct into a landmark with imaginative lighting at night.
  • Using space under the viaduct "for creative business looking for bespoke accommodation in a high quality, unusual environment".

Councillors will consider the regeneration strategies - by planners Urban Initiatives and transport consultants Peter Brett Associates - at a policy and resources committee meeting tomorrow.

Could the plans transform the city for the better or would it be millions of pounds of money that could be better spent elsewhere?

Leave your comments below.


Your Say YourThe Argus

PJ, Brighton says...
10:34am Wed 25 Jul 07

Good ideas, have to see the plans in detail to comment further, but that part of Brighton is a bit of a dump! I live right by it! lol

sean, brighton says...
10:38am Wed 25 Jul 07

Heard it all before. You only have to look at what they did with Queens Rd a few years back attempting to make a "pleasant gateway" to the city from the station down to the seafront. They came out with all these pretty artist impressions, a fancy name ('Ocean Boulevard'). What it amounted to was a bunch of new paving slabs that were covered in chewing gum & grime in no time & some colourful traffic cones at the bottom of West St. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for these improvements but only if it's genuine and not just a load of puff that soon gets forgotten about. Time after time we're confronted with 'stories' like this in the Argus. You get your hopes up & really want to believe that for once a scheme will live up to the hype, PR spin & actually become reality & improve the quality of people's lives. Lived here too long & become too cynical I guess...

Adam, Brighton says...
10:38am Wed 25 Jul 07

Great ideas, but what will happen to the traffic on the already clogged up roads around Preston Circus if you make London Rd bus only? People driving out of the city don't need to use a local bus, they are trying to leave!

Nigel Jones, Hollingdean says...
10:43am Wed 25 Jul 07

Sounds great! Lots of ugly bits being replaced with something better. Nice one.

Rob, Mile Oak says...
11:11am Wed 25 Jul 07

Don't get too excited by these plans. I'm sure Lewes District Council will object to the proposals and everyone will have to wait for 10 years before the work can be given the go ahead.

BrightonGirl, brighton says...
11:26am Wed 25 Jul 07

If this actually gets of the ground it will be the best thing in a long while for Brighton!!

Stuart Brown, Hove says...
1:01pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Move Moulscomb Station southwards to benefit the new residents of Preston Barracks? This illustrates that 'regeneration' now means development for the better off. It should mean helping areas that need investment such as Moulscoomb.

gulliver, brighton says...
1:13pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Smoke and mirrors methinks frankly. The idea of a public square at Vogue Gyratory is absurd, it has the worst air quality in the city sitting in the valley and is only going to get worse due to the Waste Transfer Station introduced by...you guessed it BHCC!
Making a City viable takes bigger balls than are currently available in Brighton. Time the old guard of usual suspects that pop up in these articles move on and let a more imaginative, capable and head strong youth make te City fulfill its potential. The current generation of McCarthy and co couldn't run a bath.

ComradeK, Brighton says...
1:39pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Very good comments so far...

But what about doing up the city's council homes and the empty council properties? Nearly 50% need upgrading to meet the govmt's Decent Homes Standard.

There's also 11,000 people on the council waiting list! We need more homes not fancy refurbishments which sees council taxpayers' money wasted on private contracts.

I'm all for making the city a pleasant place to live but the council needs to prioritise...

Peter, Saltdean says...
1:44pm Wed 25 Jul 07

I used to live next to the gyratory, and I'm all for improvements. But the devil is in the detail ... where does all the traffic go ?

daniel, brighton says...
2:04pm Wed 25 Jul 07

most of the traffic at the gyratory is caused by the bad traffic management in that area and the location of the enternace/exit to the supermarket. If this is being looked at you would hope that the traffic flow would be improved!

Lenny, Brighton says...
3:16pm Wed 25 Jul 07

I can beat Peter of Saltdean - I used to live ON the Vogue Gyratory. Rather predictably, it was shocking.

Norman, Hove says...
3:25pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Sounds great, London Road is disgusting. You never see police there but its full of criminals and druggies! Why not move moulsecombe and whitehawk to Lewes, that should improve things.

ComradeK, Brighton says...
3:34pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Norman:

So if we move Whitehawk and Mouslecoomb to Lewes who is going to deliver your mail, collect your bins, recycle for you, run your trains, buses hospitals, schools, shops, warehouses, factories... these places are working class districts that have been left to rot under successive councils. The people there are the salt of the earth and are doing the jobs that make this society run. Without these people your rubbish would just pile up around you and you'd have no NHS, schools, post, milk, food...

Only a fraction of the people in these places claim benefits so I suggest you point your criticisms elsewhere. Now read what I wrote above about council housing....

beck, says...
4:28pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Lenny wrote:
I can beat Peter of Saltdean - I used to live ON the Vogue Gyratory. Rather predictably, it was shocking.
I used to live on the hollingdean road - i wouldn't wish the noise and pollution on anyone.
As someone said, where will all the cars go?

Paul Ockenden, Vogue Gyratory says...
5:00pm Wed 25 Jul 07

It sounds a bit "silly season" to me. Last time there was a report about doing something with the Vogue Gyratory (including knocking down the supermarket) the consultants involved admitted that they hadn't actually spoken to Sainsburys.

I wonder whether that's also the case this time round?

I'm also not convinced that it's the right place for a public square - the area gets lots of through footfall, but the only people I can forsee wanting to hang around will be gangs of kids from the estates further up the road.

Don't get me wrong - it's a terrible junction right now. I just think it would be an even worse public square.

Darryl, Kemp Town says...
5:19pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Knock down the Sainsbury's? It's the least awful building around there, apart from the bus garage!

Norbert, Brighton says...
5:22pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Trouble is, any public square is wasted in Brighton. They soon get taken over by Pikeys and drug addicts, and no decent people can use them. Beggars will be delighted at this news. More wastage of tax payers money.

However, if Sainsbury's does get knocked down, how about re-building the Brighton to Kemp Town railway and extending it to Saltdean, Peacehaven etc? That would be fantastic.

warren, Moulsecoomb says...
8:12pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Consultants, read tossers, get paid lots of money to come up with some 'blue sky thinking', like moving Moulsecoomb train station.
Here's a crazy idea, boot all the students out of the ex council family homes on the Moulsecoomb estate to get the waiting lists down.

tony, brighton says...
9:34pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Sounds great in theory, but in practice, is the Council going to CPO business premises and land to ensure that these grand plans happen? If so, where does the cash come from? How will businesses be relocated and compensated? Also, are the planners ready for this brave new world; only a matter of weeks ago they refused two planning applications for high quality developments close to the vogue gyratory which would have signalled support for these plans. Why should developers try to inject cash in to the area, if all they get back is a kick in the teeth? Preston barracks has been talked about for years, and doubtless will lift the area. The rest sounds pie in the sky unless the Council sharpens its teeth.

canal man, brighton says...
9:51pm Wed 25 Jul 07

How about a canal so we can do what Manchester has! Plenty of rain to fill it and if it comes down the Lewes Road from the new stadium the s'coomers can fill it with their old prams and buggies ( enough teenage mums up there! )

Cyril Cynic, Brighton says...
11:03pm Wed 25 Jul 07

Fantasitic news for all the buy to let investors that have already invested heavily in that area. THis should add fuel to the fire on the already raging debate about affordable housing in the city. Young first time buyers move now and bag a decent investment or never moan again about the lack of opportunity for you to get on the property ladder in B&H.

gordon, brighton says...
11:39pm Wed 25 Jul 07

ComradeK wrote:
Very good comments so far... But what about doing up the city's council homes and the empty council properties? Nearly 50% need upgrading to meet the govmt's Decent Homes Standard. There's also 11,000 people on the council waiting list! We need more homes not fancy refurbishments which sees council taxpayers' money wasted on private contracts. I'm all for making the city a pleasant place to live but the council needs to prioritise...
Comradek maybe we do not all want to live in one big council estate for a city, I think you will find all new development includes social housing. There are plenty of empty council homes up north. The council needs to work for the majority, and we have enough large council estates already causing problems.
Council tenants should be more easily evicted to make them appreciate when they are housed at the taxpayers expense, and pay the rent, that would probably free up 11,000 homes. If we build council homes for everyone that wants one we would have no green belt. just because you are on the list does not mean you are in need, and many people already with council houses are not the truly needy.
Great plans though, but not sure where the traffic will go that want to leave brighton, if london road just for buses. Where are the plans for a park and ride, or maybe they realise we wont have any visitors in the future due to Brightons well known traffic jams and ridiculous road schemes.

Andy R, Hove says...
10:10am Thu 26 Jul 07

gordon wrote:
ComradeK wrote: Very good comments so far... But what about doing up the city's council homes and the empty council properties? Nearly 50% need upgrading to meet the govmt's Decent Homes Standard. There's also 11,000 people on the council waiting list! We need more homes not fancy refurbishments which sees council taxpayers' money wasted on private contracts. I'm all for making the city a pleasant place to live but the council needs to prioritise...
Comradek maybe we do not all want to live in one big council estate for a city, I think you will find all new development includes social housing. There are plenty of empty council homes up north. The council needs to work for the majority, and we have enough large council estates already causing problems. Council tenants should be more easily evicted to make them appreciate when they are housed at the taxpayers expense, and pay the rent, that would probably free up 11,000 homes. If we build council homes for everyone that wants one we would have no green belt. just because you are on the list does not mean you are in need, and many people already with council houses are not the truly needy. Great plans though, but not sure where the traffic will go that want to leave brighton, if london road just for buses. Where are the plans for a park and ride, or maybe they realise we wont have any visitors in the future due to Brightons well known traffic jams and ridiculous road schemes.
Absolute nonsense. Council tenants are not "housed at taxpayers expense". Council housing is financed from the rents the tenants pay. It is actually unlawful for local authorities to finance it from any other source. Some of the juvenile bile directed at council tenants in these discussions would be (slightly) easier to take if the authors did not reveal their crass ignorance at almost every turn.

Liz, Derby says...
1:30pm Sat 28 Jul 07

Go for it! all these ideas sound great, especially the tall buildings in the New England Quarter, add extra sparkle to Brighton skyline without using countryside to build on. Wish we up north used Brownfield sites as well as you do - we're in the dark ages up here!

Brian Butterworth, Hove says...
10:49am Fri 10 Aug 07

It's a shame that the tunnel under Elm Grove that used to go to the Kemptown Station can't be reused to link the Vogue Gyratory area to the Marina

Glenn, Riley Road says...
8:45pm Sat 22 Sep 07

I'm sure it's mostly hot air. The improvements to Saunders Park thus far have been minimal; the park is seriously blighted by Shabitat (lorries full of junk coming and going next to the kids paddling pool - you wouldn't get that in posh Queen's Park or St Anne's Wells Gardens). The dog-muck bins are often left full with no-one coming to empty them. As for banning any more takeaways, that would be good, but a new pizza place and something called 'Balti Towers' has just opened on Lewes Road, so by the time any prohibition comes in it will be too late. The most serious problem with the whole area (apart from the traffic) is that it's a student ghetto, and I don't see how a proposed 'academic corridor' will change that. The quality of life in my street (Riley Road) is seriously undermined by a very loud minority of (mainly) Sussex University students; unless something can be done to curtail the number of buy-to-lets going to students, and so maintaining a decent 'mix' of people, a few extra trees and a bit of street furniture ain't gonna make any difference. As ever with Brighton, image is everything.

Comments are closed on this article.

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »