News RSS Feed


Brighton council cleaner caught dumping waste in street

9:56pm Tuesday 15th January 2008

comment Comments (15)   Have your say »


An investigation has been launched after a road sweeper was caught on camera spraying filth all over a residential street.

Video footage clearly shows a refuse worker purposefully spilling the contents of his collection in Furze Hill, Hove.

Brighton and Hove City Council, which is responsible for the CityClean service, said it was looking into the incident after police found a used condom among the mess.

It was filmed by an eagle-eyed motorist who stopped his car to record on his mobile phone the road sweeper dumping his load.

James Benning, a 25-year-old delivery driver, from Inwood Crescent, Brighton, saw it pouring out of the cleaning van into the middle of a bus stop on Monday morning.

He reported the incident to police, believing the foul mess could have been carrying dangerous syringes and effluent.

He said: "It was disgusting. I saw a more sensible disposal of waste when I was living in India for three years.

"It looked like waste from a toilet. There were brown lumps coming out of it in a kind of red gunk. It was foul.

"There's no way it should have been dumped five feet away from the curb at the top of the hill without a drain anywhere near it.

"He was just expelling it in the middle of the road. It's definitely not right."

Privately, the council has admitted to The Argus that the road sweeper, who has not been named, was wrong to unload his rubbish in the street and then drive away.

But a spokesman for the council described the act yesterday as normal practice.

Spokesman Alan Stone said: "Drivers are required to discharge tanks close to drains and this is what he is clearly doing in the video.

"Tanks can fill with liquid in an hour and they'd otherwise have to return to the depot just to put it down another drain."

However, Mr Benning said there was not a drain in sight of the spillage.

He added: "As soon as I took the film I called the police because I just couldn't believe what I was seeing. The driver then got back into his cab and tipped the machine back so all the sediment was shifted to the end.

"Then that all came out the tap as well. There could have been anything in there, even syringes.

"It was what looked like waste from the side of the road with fag butts, lots of plastic that looked like used condoms, effluent. It was very dirty."

Police said it looked like the machine had been used to suck up rubbish and then dump it back out again after Mr Benning called them to the scene at 11.20am.

Officers later told the council to come back and clear the filth up.

A police spokeswoman said: "We told them it's better that the culprit returns to clear up what he's tipped as soon as possible.

"If an offence of fly-tipping has been committed it will be up to the council to pursue it."

Mr Stone added: "It is water and litter off the street, much of which goes down drains of its own accord.

"The police are saying it contained one condom. If this is the case, it came off the street anyway.

"Inevitably some litter also drops out. However, the driver said the area was not left in a mess.

"We've checked that location today and it is spotless, so one way or another the council has cleaned that street very well."

Gill Mitchell, the Labour group leader and former chairwoman of the council's environment committee, said: "If this is a CityClean employee and rubbish is being strewn onto the road I'd expect the council to perform an immediate investigation as to why, as this is clearly, completely unacceptable."


Your Say YourThe Argus

Roadsweeper, brighton says...
10:24pm Tue 15 Jan 08

I WONDER IF THE EAGLE EYED MOTORIST ACTUALLY STAYED AROUND LONG ENOUGH TO SEE THE OUTCOME OF THIS ROADSWEEPERS ACTIONS ? IT IS AN ACTION THAT IS COMMON WHEN WE HAVE HAD SO MUCH RAIN THESE VEHICLES HAVE TO DRAIN OFF ANY WATER THAT THEY COLLECT, AS FOR THE 'FOUL MESS' IT IS ONLY WHAT IS COLLECTED FROM THE STREETS OF BRIGHTON EVERY DAY AND ONCE THE VEHICLE HAS BEEN DRAINED OF THE EXCESS WATER THE DRIVERS ALWAYS SWEEP UP THE MESS THAT THEY HAVE CREATED, WHICH THE EAGLED EYED MOTORIST WOULD HAVE SEEN IF HE HAD STUCK AROUND

Jo, haywards heath says...
10:42pm Tue 15 Jan 08

Whilst I was initially thinking good on Mr Benning for caring about it enough to report it, I quickly went off him when I read that he phoned the police. Er, hello? No wonder we've got no coppers spare to tackle the real crimes if they get called out by silly timewasters like this bloke. Report it to the council of course but the police??!! What is the world coming to.

jayne, hove says...
12:13am Wed 16 Jan 08

Jo, do you really think the council would have been interested if it had not been reported to the police already. It would have taken phone calls galore, letters galore and weeks probably to get no response, unfortunately that has been my experience with some of the services and disjointed council departments, usually because of illness, holiday or job sharing or incapable politically correct appointed employees. If this truly was a form of flytipping and laziness then the police should be involved and the person prosecuted. This kind of anti social behaviour is just as destructive to a city and on a par with shoplifting and petty crime. This city needs a keep brighton and hove tidy campaign as well as a revamped green cross code campaign, as another bug bare is pedestrians walking out in to the road without looking expecting cars or buses to have zero stopping distances.

council taxpayer, brighton says...
1:50am Wed 16 Jan 08

Roadsweeper wrote:
I WONDER IF THE EAGLE EYED MOTORIST ACTUALLY STAYED AROUND LONG ENOUGH TO SEE THE OUTCOME OF THIS ROADSWEEPERS ACTIONS ? IT IS AN ACTION THAT IS COMMON WHEN WE HAVE HAD SO MUCH RAIN THESE VEHICLES HAVE TO DRAIN OFF ANY WATER THAT THEY COLLECT, AS FOR THE 'FOUL MESS' IT IS ONLY WHAT IS COLLECTED FROM THE STREETS OF BRIGHTON EVERY DAY AND ONCE THE VEHICLE HAS BEEN DRAINED OF THE EXCESS WATER THE DRIVERS ALWAYS SWEEP UP THE MESS THAT THEY HAVE CREATED, WHICH THE EAGLED EYED MOTORIST WOULD HAVE SEEN IF HE HAD STUCK AROUND
yep, he stayed around. and it was still there when the roadsweeper had gone and the police arrived.

watch the video and weep!


caeos, says...
2:10am Wed 16 Jan 08

suprised the bus company didnt get blamed for that one

Sisyphus, Augeas says...
9:16am Wed 16 Jan 08

is it on U tube yet?

Roadsweeper, Brighton says...
10:54am Wed 16 Jan 08

council taxpayer wrote:
Roadsweeper wrote: I WONDER IF THE EAGLE EYED MOTORIST ACTUALLY STAYED AROUND LONG ENOUGH TO SEE THE OUTCOME OF THIS ROADSWEEPERS ACTIONS ? IT IS AN ACTION THAT IS COMMON WHEN WE HAVE HAD SO MUCH RAIN THESE VEHICLES HAVE TO DRAIN OFF ANY WATER THAT THEY COLLECT, AS FOR THE 'FOUL MESS' IT IS ONLY WHAT IS COLLECTED FROM THE STREETS OF BRIGHTON EVERY DAY AND ONCE THE VEHICLE HAS BEEN DRAINED OF THE EXCESS WATER THE DRIVERS ALWAYS SWEEP UP THE MESS THAT THEY HAVE CREATED, WHICH THE EAGLED EYED MOTORIST WOULD HAVE SEEN IF HE HAD STUCK AROUND
yep, he stayed around. and it was still there when the roadsweeper had gone and the police arrived. watch the video and weep!
watched the 10sec video and it does not show the sweeper leaving the area so how do you know it was left ? i know this cleaner and he is a most concientious worker who would not have left the mess there. so have watched the video and am still not weeping !

stef, brighton says...
1:00pm Wed 16 Jan 08

forget about the rubbish being dumped - im suprised the police didn't fine the driver for using a mobile phone at the wheel! how would you get out of that one!!!

Sue, Hove says...
1:34pm Wed 16 Jan 08

road sweeper dumping his load

Snigger

larry marchant, brighton says...
3:36pm Wed 16 Jan 08

these mechanical sweepers suck up rubbish but when its raining which as been alot lately the driver of the vehical as tostop now and again to release the rain water or before you go back to the yard which this man was doing

Gazza, Horsham says...
8:26pm Wed 16 Jan 08

The council said its normal practise for council road sweeper to dump excess water sludge in their tanks instead of going back to their yard In other words to save time.

My question is if a private company swept up a road due to lets say a building site making mess on the road would they let the privet road sweeper dump there waste down the drain. I think not and they would probably receive a fine as well.

Will environmental health get involved and then fine the council for this stupid practise, And then council taxpayers will end up paying for in the long run?

As they say who councils the Councils

Yours Faithfully

Mr Air Born Particles

PS (that smells nice) I don’t feel to well now.

Declan, Brighton says...
8:37pm Wed 16 Jan 08

You’d think this man had committed a heinous crime “watch the video and weep!” I did and I saw 10 seconds of nothing. Oh, wow, a bloody condom on the road, where it came from in the first place. Get a life mate. It was cleaned up, and if India has a better system and as quick to clear up mess, I never saw it when I was there. Getting real, would be another idea for him. The police informed the council and seemed not too bothered about it. What is sad about this is the Argus making such a story about it. Instead of looking to knock the place we live in so much and declaring it as news when it is clearly a miner incidence. Brighton & Hove is one of the cleanest cities I’ve see and with the weather these poor people have suffered in the last couple of days I think that a miner thing should be looked at as a silly mistake and not as an over the top rant by a sad man.

elvis fan-tcb, brighton says...
7:50am Thu 17 Jan 08

please dont make me laugh!was you trying out your new phone what you got for christmas?was you driving at the time you filmed it?i hope nobody filmed you whilst you was doing that as im sure THAT IS against the law.or was it that the council worker was just parked where you wanted to be?i mean,we all know that delivery drivers always park legally whilst doing their job,dont we?
this worker is doing something that i have seen done several times-draining off into a drain(there is one just down the road)any rubbish or water that he has picked up has come from our roads,so moan at the people who dump it in our city with no care-not at the poor road sweeper.this is a common practice all over the country,and so long as he cleaned it up after he had drained out,then i see no problem.and sorry-i have not lived in india,but if a incident like this would have been reported to thier police,i think they wouldnt have even bothered with it,which is what our police probably wanted to do,and get on with some useful police work!let the road cleaners get on with thier work and leave them be.most of them do a wonderful job,in terrible weather and for not a lot of money

Jim Yule, Chester, Cheshire says...
3:26pm Thu 17 Jan 08

I ran a Road Sweeper Hire company for many years. It is normal practise to drain off excess water from the machine. If this was not done, especially when it’s raining, the operator would have to go to a land fill site every 20 minutes; this would prove to be a very expensive and totally inefficient exercise.
What the operator did wrong was; he should have stopped by a road grid and drained the water into it, he should then have swept up any hard detritus that was left on the road way.
Other than that he did nothing wrong.. the Police have far more serious thing to exercise their energies on.

Steve King, UK says...
4:12pm Sat 19 Apr 08

Where is the video ?

Brown lumps !! omg you mean mud, unless the people of Brighton have Bowel movements in the roads i`m sure all will be fine.. :D


Comments are closed on this article.

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »