News RSS Feed


Dimas banner

Gardener cuts off arm in chainsaw accident

12:10am Tuesday 30th September 2008

comment Comments (11)   Have your say »

By Andy Whelan »

A gardener cut off his arm in a freak chainsaw accident - and his neighbour tried to save the severed limb by putting it in a bag of frozen pastries.

John Stirling, 59, was tonight undergoing emergency surgery with doctors trying to reattach his arm.

Neighbour Steve Francis told how Mr Stirling calmly knocked on his door and said: “Please help, I’ve just cut my arm off.”

Mr Francis, 49, said: “He wasn’t screaming, he was as relaxed as can be.

“I didn’t realise anything was wrong until I looked down and saw his arm was missing.

“I ran inside to call the ambulance and he sat outside on a stool.

“I came out and tied his arm up with a belt and towels, the ambulance people talked me through it.

“But through it all he sat there talking away like it was normal.

“When the ambulance came they put him on a stretcher and asked where the arm was.

“The paramedics were working on him so I went up the road and put it in a plastic Tesco shopping bag.

“I then put it in another bag with frozen pastries in to keep it cold.

“Then I gave the bag to one of the paramedics and they took it to hospital in the ambulance.

“He’s a brave man, I’ll give him that. I couldn’t believe he didn’t faint.”

The ambulance arrived at the house in Ambleside Avenue, Telscombe Cliffs, at 11.14am today and took him to the Royal Sussex County Hospital in Brighton before he was transferred to the Queen Victoria Hospital in East Grinstead.

Mr Stirling, a father, who has lived in the house since 1980, is believed to have been cutting a tree when his chainsaw slipped and ripped through his arm. Mr Francis said he cut his arm off from below the elbow.

Mr Francis said: “He was gardening. He came over to me because he knew I would be home because I’m doing decorating work.

“You wonder how you will react when you come across an accident, whether you will do the right thing, but I’m glad I reacted the way I did.

“I wouldn’t say I was brave, I just didn’t have a choice.

“It is surprising what you will do when you have to.”

Mr Stirling was still in the operating theatre late this evening. His condition was described as critical.


Your Say YourArgus

Lil, Worthing says...
8:15am Tue 30 Sep 08

Oh my! I sincerely hope the op' is succcessful. What a terrifying and horrible thing to happen!

feline1, Brighton says...
10:12am Tue 30 Sep 08

lol Even with a story as gut-wrenching as this, journalist "Andy Whelan" still feels the need to pointlessly spin and exaggerate it. The poor guy did not cut his "arm" off, he cut he forearm off, below the elbow.
Of course, for dramatic effect, the Argus neglects to mention this until the end of the article, thus rendering the everything before that ludicrous! I mean how on earth was the guy's neighbour going to fit an ENTIRE ARM in a Tesco bag? Or apply a belt tourniquet around the guy's shoulder?!?

Moreover the interesting psychological side of the story is left completely unexplored - presumeably the guy didn't faint or scream because he was in shock? But the Argus just glosses over this and mutters something about him being "brave".

garyc, worthing says...
11:03am Tue 30 Sep 08

feline1 wrote:
lol Even with a story as gut-wrenching as this, journalist "Andy Whelan" still feels the need to pointlessly spin and exaggerate it. The poor guy did not cut his "arm" off, he cut he forearm off, below the elbow. Of course, for dramatic effect, the Argus neglects to mention this until the end of the article, thus rendering the everything before that ludicrous! I mean how on earth was the guy's neighbour going to fit an ENTIRE ARM in a Tesco bag? Or apply a belt tourniquet around the guy's shoulder?!?Moreover the interesting psychological side of the story is left completely unexplored - presumeably the guy didn't faint or scream because he was in shock? But the Argus just glosses over this and mutters something about him being "brave".
why do u critisize everything?why bother going on the argus website?why dont u get a life?

I dont see anything in your comments acyually feeling sorry for this man
I wish him a speedy recovery

fed up!, steyning says...
11:10am Tue 30 Sep 08

feline1 wrote:
lol Even with a story as gut-wrenching as this, journalist you are such a sad person! i fell sorry for you! does it matter if he cut his whole or half arm off really????!!! this poor man has had a very frightening accident and you use it to have another pop at the argus! if you dont like it dont read it im sure you wont be missed!
my thoughts are with this poor man and his family!

tilburyre, Worthing says...
11:13am Tue 30 Sep 08

What, GaryC, is wrong in criticising the reporting? Feline's comments are entirely justified. If we don't make these comments the standard of reporting will never improve.

And I see no reason to feel sorry for someone just because the Argus decides to report the story. Other poeple suffer just as traumatic accidents but you don't feel sorry for them becuase they are not in the paper.

fed up!, steyning says...
11:13am Tue 30 Sep 08

feline1 you are such a sad person! i fell sorry for you! does it matter if he cut his whole or half arm off really????!!! this poor man has had a very frightening accident and you use it to have another pop at the argus! if you dont like it dont read it im sure you wont be missed!
my thoughts are with this poor man and his family!

feline1, Brighton says...
12:31pm Tue 30 Sep 08

well the headline says he "chopped" it off ... with a saw.

Which i guess is better than sawing it off with an axe. Or a blunt spoon.

parvenu, Brighton says...
12:36pm Tue 30 Sep 08

feline1 is being over critical. I'd say the report is pretty fair to all-concerned, including the victim.
I get the impression that whatever the reporter did, it would be wrong for Feline.
I'm sure we all wish the victim well.

Jools, Sussex says...
1:05pm Tue 30 Sep 08

tilburyre wrote:
What, GaryC, is wrong in criticising the reporting? Feline's comments are entirely justified. If we don't make these comments the standard of reporting will never improve.And I see no reason to feel sorry for someone just because the Argus decides to report the story. Other poeple suffer just as traumatic accidents but you don't feel sorry for them becuase they are not in the paper.
The standard of reporting has always been criticised but hasn't improved the standard of journalism, that's so obvious. What's also obvious is that if someone has a 'traumatic accident' you can't feel sorry for them if you don't know about it !!!

jo w, haywards heath says...
9:43pm Tue 30 Sep 08

Wishing Mr S a speedy recovery and how fab to have such a calm and sensible neighbour in Mr F. I'd probably have passed out, vomited etc etc if I'd been in his position. I hope they share a good laugh about this story over a cup of tea when Mr S is fit and healthy again.

cantmoveforbins, Hove says...
10:57pm Tue 30 Sep 08

Yes, Severs forearm is more elgant that 'cuts off arm' - makes it sound like he clamped the saw under his armpit for a moment or something.. anyway, he did well to stay calm and collected and will hopefully make a full recovery.
"I ran inside to call the ambulance and he sat outside on a stool" .. I'd be sitting on a pretty big stool too if it was me .. :)

Your sayYourArgus

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE The Argus account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?
Mr Striling arrives at hospital Mr Striling arrives at hospital

Sponsored Links


Local Services


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »