Brighton News RSS Feed


Brighton and Hove bin strikes could be ended today


Binmen in Brighton and Hove will vote today on whether to suspend their two week strike against proposed pay cuts.

With large piles of rubbish already building up across the city, the 300 striking workers will hold a meeting at 11am at the Hollingdean Depot to discuss a new pay offer from Brighton and Hove City Council.

The deal was presented to their union, the GMB, by the council after two crisis meetings yesterday.

Our report from the picket line at Hollingdean depot on the first day of the strike.

GMB branch secretary Mark Turner said he was happy enough with the offer to present it to the workers today but the decision to accept it would be up to them.

Mr Turner said last night: "We will hold a ballot at the end of that meeting over whether to suspend the strikes for 56 days. I can't pre-empt what the members will do. It is an offer I am willing to present to them but I don't know whether they will take it."

If the CityClean staff vote in favour of suspending the strike they will return to work on Wednesday morning and start clearing the piles of rubbish which have built up.

The two week strike started yesterday and followed a work-to-rule which began last Thursday.

The 300 workers are among 800 across the council who have been threatened with pay cuts of between £2,000 and £8,000 each.

The CityClean staff have an average wage of around £19,000.

The council has proposed the cuts to meet new equalities laws which mean it cannot pay some unskilled workers more than others.

At present refuse staff have a higher salary than others, including teaching assistants and library workers.

It has tried to lower pay at CityClean rather than raise it elsewhere.

Both the council and GMB declined to disclose the details of the latest offer last night.

Council leader Mary Mears spoke about the dispute for the first time yesterday.

She said: “The council has made a proposal to the GMB about how it intends to implement fair pay and the union has agreed to put it to its members tomorrow.

"We feel it balances our duty to protect the pay of our employees while avoiding passing on unnecessary costs to the council taxpayer.

“We’re hopeful the union will accept the offer so that our staff can return to work as soon as possible.”



Your Say YourArgus

sharronw, says...
7:44am Tue 10 Nov 09

Well lets see what the offer is my husband will be there 11am for the metting.

Asbo, says...
8:18am Tue 10 Nov 09

I am have ataken a substanial drop in wages to keep my job through the reccession. I was asked to loose my bonus payments but my basic wage has stayed the same. What City Clean is trying to do is just taking the biscuit! I have every sympathy with the binmen and all front line public service workers!

r2dean2, brighton says...
8:30am Tue 10 Nov 09

DON'T GIVE IN AT THE FIRST SIGN OF A SMALL OFFER, OR INCREASE, STAND FIRM GUYS, AS YOU ALL HAVE SAID..... NOT ONE PENNY!!!

WE'RE BEHIND YOU!!!

bbrh, Brighton says...
8:41am Tue 10 Nov 09

Lets hope its a fair offer and Cityclean are able to get back to work. As Mrs Mears says the council has to balance the interests of its employees with the council tax payers.

abinman, says...
8:44am Tue 10 Nov 09

We will stand firm and also to the people that have had wage cuts your wage will go back up when the reccession is over, our pay will stay low for ever so thats why we are fighting for our rights and once again thank u for your support and hopefully by fri all the rubbish will be cleared up :)

Bennn, Kemptown, Brighton says...
10:14am Tue 10 Nov 09

It is great to see so much support for you guys. I thought I would be reading "get back to work you lazy bunch" all day long in the comments section but it seems that the majority are behind you. Of course it is terrible to see the rubbish piling up everywhere but the Council are to blame, not you.

Boris D, Btn says...
10:39am Tue 10 Nov 09

Everyone is having to take pay cuts, why are the bin men any different, there are loads of unemployed people that would be grateful of a job

Andy R, Hove says...
10:50am Tue 10 Nov 09

Boris D wrote:
Everyone is having to take pay cuts, why are the bin men any different, there are loads of unemployed people that would be grateful of a job
No they're not.

Bennn, Kemptown, Brighton says...
10:51am Tue 10 Nov 09

Boris D wrote:
Everyone is having to take pay cuts, why are the bin men any different, there are loads of unemployed people that would be grateful of a job
Well that's "everyone's" fault for not fighting against pay cuts. At least the bin men aren't afraid of going on strike. I see the bosses never get pay cuts!

RAS Putin, Brighton says...
11:01am Tue 10 Nov 09

abinman wrote:
We will stand firm and also to the people that have had wage cuts your wage will go back up when the reccession is over, our pay will stay low for ever so thats why we are fighting for our rights and once again thank u for your support and hopefully by fri all the rubbish will be cleared up :)
Give 'em hell, binman!

RickH, Hove says...
11:38am Tue 10 Nov 09

One of the oddities in this dispute is whether (rightly or wrongly) that some refuse collectors are facing a large salary decrease. However, what interests me is in what world do they live where an average of £19K is seen as a reasonable 'salary' for what amounts to an unskilled job. This figure is way in excess of many salaries 'enjoyed' by workings requiring a greater or more diverse skill-set and would ahve topped my old salary which was paid to me following 11 years of direct experience and formal qualifications (to HND level). Maybe time for a little perspective on both sides of the dispute?

UglyAmerican, Hotlanta says...
12:20pm Tue 10 Nov 09

I've seen a lot of comments griping about refuse collection being an "unskilled" job.

It doesn't really matter. Public sanitation & sewers are probably the most important developments in human history, particularly around the concept of cities. Without the ability to move human waste, in all forms, away from the population in a controlled fashion, you would be experiencing rampant disease that would make the plague look like the sniffles.

The definition of "unskilled" is constantly evolving. Soon enough, the ability to operate a computer will be considered a baseline skill that all the workforce should have, and no special considerations will be given to those who can do so. Many capabilities that are considered a part of the basic working skill set today were once considered special capabilities. Reading & basic math come to mind.

Asbo, says...
12:36pm Tue 10 Nov 09

The 19k salary is for a driver not a binman. A binmans salary is a long way below that despite what the media portrays.

r2dean2, brighton says...
12:59pm Tue 10 Nov 09

About £16.900 for a binman
£14.500 appox for a street sweeper.
not alot really for the abuse they get, and thats just from the cityclean managers who could to arrange a prayer in a church, let alone a bin collection.

Tatty Bojangles, Brighton says...
1:07pm Tue 10 Nov 09

If the trucks are not being used, any chance i could borrow one???? theres a bit of a mess on the bottom of my street and could do with having a bit of a clean up. apparantly it is common knowledge that when the bin is full, you are supposed to throw all your crap straight onto the street. love it! be nice to borrow one just to try and turn our once nice city back form the dump it is becoming, also havent had my shots for Plague yet so really want to try and avoid it if i can and the man living in the pile of rubbish on my street is starting to become quite territorial. cheers for now. ps: let me know what time i can collect the keys.

Granny, Brighton says...
1:10pm Tue 10 Nov 09

Why should a driver get more than the bin men? He sits on his backside all day while the bin men do all the heavy work and all the walking to and fro. Seems a bit unfair to me.

Voice of Unreason, B&H says...
1:26pm Tue 10 Nov 09

Granny wrote:
Why should a driver get more than the bin men? He sits on his backside all day while the bin men do all the heavy work and all the walking to and fro. Seems a bit unfair to me.
Ahhh, Granny - he is "skilled"...
I know, it makes me laugh too....and yet street sweepers who do a job that really is tough, and none of us would want to do, are only on £13,000.
I think the wages should be reversed.

Voice of Unreason, B&H says...
1:31pm Tue 10 Nov 09

"About £16.900 for a binman
£14.500 appox for a street sweeper.
not alot really for the abuse they get...."
People keep mentioning this 'abuse' What abuse?
People have every right to have a go if their rubbish is left behind, or left strewn all over road as it very often is where I live.
We pay their wages. That gives us the right to complain if the job's not done properly.

RickH, Hove says...
1:59pm Tue 10 Nov 09

r2dean2 wrote:
About £16.900 for a binman £14.500 appox for a street sweeper. not alot really for the abuse they get, and thats just from the cityclean managers who could to arrange a prayer in a church, let alone a bin collection.
What abuse? Strikes me you're grasping at straws to justify a wage that is obviosly inflated when compared to other jobs with a similar weight in both the public and private sectors; whether its £19K for a driver, £16.9K for a 'bin lifter' or the reported average of £19k - time to get real chaps!

deni, brighton says...
2:46pm Tue 10 Nov 09

Where does the £14,500 come from I read on an earlier comment from a road sweeper that he was earning £18,000 a year.

Voice of Unreason, B&H says...
3:46pm Tue 10 Nov 09

deni wrote:
Where does the £14,500 come from I read on an earlier comment from a road sweeper that he was earning £18,000 a year.
Well, someone who claimed to be a street sweeper on a previous posting said they earned £13k and were going to have to take a £2k drop.
So someone's making it up - or maybe the council is so stupid that they employ 2 people doing the same job with a pay differential of 5 grand!
All of the above are possibilities...

Jack Cade, Lewes says...
10:18pm Tue 10 Nov 09

Lets get this straight. This is nothing to do with the recession. Anyway, are people creating less rubbish than 18 months ago? No! (And before anybody asks the Council don't collect business waste). Only in Britain could we use equal pay as an excuse to cut people's pay. If you think the Council is so well paid why don't you apply for a job there?

nomates, says...
8:07am Wed 11 Nov 09

I can't believe this pay row will be finish here. The legal justification for classifying bin men as skilled and teaching assistants as unskilled will make very interesting reading!

Comments are closed on this article.

Brighton and Hove bin strikes could be ended today Thumbnail for media_id 0 Brighton and Hove bin strikes could be ended today Brighton and Hove bin strikes could be ended today

Brighton and Hove bin strikes could be ended today

300 refuse workers are striking over pay cuts

Piles of rubbish have built up across the city

The workers have refused to take any cuts




Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »