News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


Stress of commuting cutting Brighton and Hove life expectancy


The stress of travelling is knocking a year off the lives of commuters, researchers have found.

A new study shows people living in Brighton and Hove and travelling up to London each day can expect to die a year earlier than the national average for people earning similar wages to themselves.

Analysts Club Vita, who carried out the study, identified the areas where people of a given income level can expect to live significantly longer or shorter lives than the 79.6 year average.

It found the stresses and strains of coping with packed trains, delays and disruptions can have a long term impact on regular travellers from Brighton and Hove and other commuter towns.

Shelley Atlas, the chairwoman of Brighton Line Commuters group, said she was not surprised by the findings.

She said: “At the moment people are worried about keeping their jobs so they want to make sure they are in the office and at work on time.

“When you are having to deal with delays and late trains it just adds to the pressure.”

Club Vita consultant Andrew Gaches said the research suggested the faster pace of life often blamed for a shorter life expectancy in London was now spreading beyond the capital.

Comments(15)

censored says...
3:02pm Mon 12 Apr 10

"A study has found apples have thinner skins than oranges"

The study is fundamentally flawed. Living with a short commute and a good wage will buy you a better life in the West Country than it does in Brighton. Not least because the kind of work might be less pressured, you might have a larger home, better air quality, your salary goes further in a cheaper part of the world etc etc.

But that's not comparable to Brighton commuters. The alternative for these people isn't a job in the West Country, it's the same job but living in London.

And I'll bet that people who earn, say £30k and commute to London from Brighton, have better lives and live longer than people who earn £30k and live in London.

yorkie44 says...
3:22pm Mon 12 Apr 10

Travelling to London for a well paid job probably results in a longer life than living in a deprived area of Brighton with no job!!!

Spanners says...
3:24pm Mon 12 Apr 10

Bang on the money censored - the comparasion is flawed

Angryoldman says...
4:59pm Mon 12 Apr 10

Not to mention the ten years lost spent sat on the bus/train.

UglyAmerican says...
6:21pm Mon 12 Apr 10

Angryoldman wrote:
Not to mention the ten years lost spent sat on the bus/train.
It is only "lost" if you allow it to be, and in that case it is deservedly so.

RickH says...
6:26pm Mon 12 Apr 10

UglyAmerican wrote:
Angryoldman wrote: Not to mention the ten years lost spent sat on the bus/train.
It is only "lost" if you allow it to be, and in that case it is deservedly so.
Hear hear. I studied for, and passed, my (third) degree whilst commuting. Now my employer has given me a lap-top I can work on train and spend less time in the office. Winners (as opposed whingers) all round methinks!

Fercri Sakes says...
7:18pm Mon 12 Apr 10

I'd blame their early deaths on what these commuters get up to on Friday to Sunday, not the travelling.

Kevin1978 says...
10:02pm Mon 12 Apr 10

censored wrote:
"A study has found apples have thinner skins than oranges"

The study is fundamentally flawed. Living with a short commute and a good wage will buy you a better life in the West Country than it does in Brighton. Not least because the kind of work might be less pressured, you might have a larger home, better air quality, your salary goes further in a cheaper part of the world etc etc.

But that's not comparable to Brighton commuters. The alternative for these people isn't a job in the West Country, it's the same job but living in London.

And I'll bet that people who earn, say £30k and commute to London from Brighton, have better lives and live longer than people who earn £30k and live in London.
Then again moving to and living in Canada on C$ 70 000 is better than working and living in Britain!

cheezburger says...
10:31pm Mon 12 Apr 10

Every time i see a story with 'a report says', or 'studies show' i just think of Ben Goldacres Bad Science. These stories are just useless. Reducing life expectancy by a year? Rubbish. What sort of tolerance did they use? Did they have a control group? Where is this study? Who commissioned it? Dont waste our time.

kayblue says...
3:45am Tue 13 Apr 10

I agree with Kevin 1978. I commuted from Brighton to London for only two weeks in July 2006 as I finished the six-month lease on my flat and it was absolute hell. I worked next to Liverpool Street Station so I found new living arrangements along the northern edge of London to avoid another miserable commute. However, once I was made redundant, I returned to Canada and although I do not make $70,000 I am happier living here - and the commute takes only 30 minutes by bus!

Tye says...
7:16am Tue 13 Apr 10

Can someone on £30k afford to live in sussex and commute up to London as censored suggest?

I'm getting the vibes censored is Very "mature" and sadly NOT censored ;-)

LimpWristed says...
1:23pm Tue 13 Apr 10

Tye wrote:
Can someone on £30k afford to live in sussex and commute up to London as censored suggest?

I'm getting the vibes censored is Very "mature" and sadly NOT censored ;-)
Valid point. £30k in London probably means you sweep the streets or empty bins. Last time I checked I didn't see any high vis jackets on the long morning commute.

RickH says...
1:33pm Tue 13 Apr 10

Tye wrote:
Can someone on £30k afford to live in sussex and commute up to London as censored suggest? I'm getting the vibes censored is Very "mature" and sadly NOT censored ;-)
Yes: my first wage when commuting from Hove to London was £22k (in 2001). It still worked out cheaper than living in London.

censored says...
5:00pm Tue 13 Apr 10

Ummm... yes... I've commuted to London for 8 years, starting out on 20k and only 2 years ago did I go above 30k...

And no, I'm not very mature at all. Either figuratively or in age.

FC says...
9:40am Wed 14 Apr 10

yorkie44 wrote:
Travelling to London for a well paid job probably results in a longer life than living in a deprived area of Brighton with no job!!!
What, when you get a free house and free money? I don't think so.


Most popular






Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses