Reviewing the green dream

Community composting was launched at St Peter's Church and the Brighthelm Centre in Brighton Community composting was launched at St Peter's Church and the Brighthelm Centre in Brighton

On being elected, Green politicians at Brighton and Hove City Council promised they would try to create the greenest and most sustainable city in the country. TIM RIDGWAY finds out how the green dream is evolving.

Key 

Green:

Green = On Target 

Amber = Nearly on target/not enough information

Red = not meeting target

ECONOMY

Amber:

Carbon footprint (per resident)

2009 data showed it had reduced by 15.6% to 4.8 tonnes per person since 2005, short of the 16% reduction target.

The 2012 target for the year is 4.55 tonnes per person - a 20% reduction on 2005. Data is not yet available.

Amber:

Carbon footprint (council)

38,034 kilo tonnes Latest data indicates it had seen a 3.3% reduction in emissions between 2010/11 and 2011/12.

However the council missed its target to reduce emissions to 37,182.

A 4% reduction target has been set for housing, schools, corporate buildings, street lighting, fleet fuel and work-related travel for next year.

The local authority is about to start developing a programme to become zero carbon which will be in place within 3 years.

Amber:

Green business

Six businesses are accredited to the Green Tourism Business Scheme. There are 16 across East Sussex and 22 in West Sussex.

Related links

Amber:

Solar panels

The council planned to install solar panels on thousands of public buildings.

However government plans to reduce the amount of money it pays for power generated under the Feed In Tariff has limited this to 1,600 council homes. A few public buildings will also benefit.

Households

Red:

Household waste sent for reuse, recycling and composting – 28%

This is well below the regional and national average. The council set no target for this year however in 2012/13 they want 32%.

A council spokesman said: “Recycling rates tend to be lower in cities than in less densely populated areas.

“This is down to a number of factors such as residents having less space to store their recycling and higher turnover of population. In April this year we introduced a communal recycling trial in Brunswick and Adelaide ward in Hove.

“Feedback has shown that most people prefer this service to the black box collection and that the tonnage of material collected for recycling has increased significantly. We have applied for Government funding to extend this scheme in the city centre subject to consultation.”

Green:

Green:

Municipal waste sent to landfill – 26.8%

No target is set for this year however 2012/13 target of 11.6%.

 

Green:

Waste that cannot be or is not separated for recycling or composting (per household) – 581kg

2012/13 target of 602kg. Current results show this indicator is on track to meet this.

Red:

Green waste collection – not offered

A council spokesman said: “The most sustainable way for dealing with green waste is home composting. The council subsidises composters and supports community composting schemes, particularly in areas where people don’t have a lot of outside space.

“Experience in other areas has shown that green waste collections increase the total volume of waste collected as people are less inclined to compost at home. This increases the cost of dealing with waste.”

 

Green:

Energy efficiency of 11,000 council homes

Increase from 76.6% in 2010/11 to 76.8% 

Green:

Increase number of allotment plots – 2,934

An increase of 116 allotment plots in the city during 2011/12

Red:

Allotment waiting list – 2,071

Demand for allotment plots in the city is high. The number of residents awaiting a plot has risen during 2011/12 by 357.

TRANSPORT

Green:

Cycle parking – 2,647

In the last year 379 more stands were installed

Amber:

Bus journeys – 43 million

Brighton and Hove is one of the best performing authorities in terms of bus passenger journeys.

There is a target of an average increase of 800,000 passenger journeys per year.

That has not been met for 2011/12 but it is still an increase on previous years. The target for 2012/13 is 44.55 million.

Amber:

Bus services running on time – 89%

Drop from 91% in 2010/11 but bosses put this down to extensive roadworks across the city.

Services are on average 42 seconds late.

Amber:

Carbon Dioxide emissions due to transport

No up-to-date figures are available. However the council aims to meet its target of 306 kilo tonnes – down from the 2009 figure of 317ktn

Red:

Adults and children killed or seriously injured in road traffic incidents – 172 (2011)

6 people were killed, and 168 people seriously injured in road traffic accidents during 2011.

146 is the number of people forecast by the Department for Transport to be killed or seriously injured in road traffic accidents in Brighton and Hove in 2011/12.

Amber:

Cost of transport (council) – down from £2 million to £1.8 million.

Due to fewer private vehicle miles were claimed by staff and fewer train journeys

ENVIRONMENT

Green:

Sites of Special Scientific Interest

The city’s two SSSIs, Brighton to Newhaven Cliffs and Castle Hill, near Woodingdean, both meet the Government’s targets and are in good condition

Red:

Water

The groundwater currently fails to meet the set criteria for quantity.

This is due to overall water use being high and two water company abstractions being investigated for potential environmental impacts The current status of quality is ‘good’ but it is flagged as ‘at risk’ This is due to increase use of pesticides and nitrates and leaking sewers.

One planet living

The city council’s Green administration plans to become the most sustainable city in the country relies on the One Planet Living principle.

This is a global initiative which is based about enjoying a high quality of life within a fair share of the earth's resources.

Among the ten principles are transport, culture, zero waste, zero carbon and wildlife.

Council leader Jason Kitcat said: “Work has already begun to bring the council closer to achieving One Planet Living status.

“New energy saving lighting at the Brighton Centre, for example, is expected to cut carbon dioxide emissions by 23.5 tonnes a year, and save at least £41,000 a year on electricity bills.

"We know things could be better and there are some big challenges to overcome to achieve One Planet Living status.

“We are focusing on schemes that not only improve quality of life for people and the environment in Brighton and Hove, but many of them will save us money now and in the long term.”

This council is developing a three year programme which will form the basis of their 25 year long term vision to reduce the ecological footprint of the city to a One Planet level.

Comments(34)

HJarrs says...
3:25pm Sat 8 Sep 12

As a Green voter I am pleased that any progress has been made when considering both the financial situation in the country and that it is a first time minority administration.

My main concern was that, being in power for the first time, they would not get to grips with administration at what must be the most challenging time for local government in decades and also to be pragmatic. I need not have worried. B&H has so far weathered the worst of the cuts far better than most councils and despite what many commenters may say there has been no big change but rather a steady tacking towards a better, greener city.

I am sure that people will pick holes in this policy and that policy but in the round I think they have done ok.

By the time of the next election there will be a lot more progress on the ground and B&H will have weathered the economic storm better than most.

fredflintstone1 says...
3:27pm Sat 8 Sep 12

So Cllr Kitcat has now admitted that the Greens want zero wildlife in the city? Is that why they're planning to hack down another area of trees in Wild Park, in their bid to convert it to a sheep farm?

ruberducker says...
3:29pm Sat 8 Sep 12

"so they failled in their own targets for carbon polution,and expect a growth of more bus journeys to increase by 1.5 million"that makes sence,no wonder lucas is bailing out.as should the right minded people's opinion of this stupid current council..

inadaptado says...
5:03pm Sat 8 Sep 12

Does nobody check the pieces before going online? You put a key at the beginning that has not been used at all. You know how to change the colour of the font, right?

Maxwell's Ghost says...
5:13pm Sat 8 Sep 12

Recycling rates are low because this council refuses to deal with households who do not recycle including the 30,000 students in the community.
Bags and bags of waste are piled up in student areas as the wheelie bins are full and the kids dont recycle and Cityclean just leave it outside houses while sticking silly 'oops' tape over boxes of recycling which accidentally get mixed up or a passerby drops a can in the bottle box of locals who do try to recycle. My neighbours have stopped recycling as the council don't bother getting everyone to do it.
If a green administration cannot be bothered to tackle the basics such as recycling they can stuff their solar panels where the sun doesn't shine.
As for all this carbon footprint targets a pointless waste of time when China, south America and other emerging economies are tearing the world apart by the hour.
Breathe while you can. Your locally grown raspberries won't save us.

Dirk Von Roden says...
6:45pm Sat 8 Sep 12

the only thing the Greens have done is alienate car users and tourists ! they have created a permit only city for parking! they say that they will hold meetings to discuss parking meters in an area have they heck as like !! Albion st where although some folk park irresponsibly most are responsible they have installed meters with no consultation!! the greens are just out to ruin this city ! having a blue badge the cost does not really affect me but I do feel for those who have to pay through the nose for the chance of parking outside their own house!! just a thought but dont we pay rates and car tax for the use of the rd already????? so why should we buy a permit ! and the questionaire sent by B+H council have just sent out "TOO **** late " be as well using it for loo roll

ruberducker says...
6:53pm Sat 8 Sep 12

inadaptado wrote:
Does nobody check the pieces before going online? You put a key at the beginning that has not been used at all. You know how to change the colour of the font, right?
sorry hav'nt got my head that far up my own arse to worry about grammer and puctuation

Morpheus says...
8:16pm Sat 8 Sep 12

ruberducker wrote:
inadaptado wrote:
Does nobody check the pieces before going online? You put a key at the beginning that has not been used at all. You know how to change the colour of the font, right?
sorry hav'nt got my head that far up my own arse to worry about grammer and puctuation
You also don't care about spelling. Perhaps you should try your own suggestion since your head doesn't seem to be much good for anything else.

Sarah Booker says...
8:24pm Sat 8 Sep 12

inadaptado wrote:
Does nobody check the pieces before going online? You put a key at the beginning that has not been used at all. You know how to change the colour of the font, right?
The colour styles for each paragraph all appeared in preview. Something has stripped them out of the story.

gnarlychaos says...
2:45am Sun 9 Sep 12

Green party.This is your one shot. The next election will let you know just what local people think of you.Start packing now .

ruberducker says...
5:39am Sun 9 Sep 12

Morpheus wrote:
ruberducker wrote:
inadaptado wrote:
Does nobody check the pieces before going online? You put a key at the beginning that has not been used at all. You know how to change the colour of the font, right?
sorry hav'nt got my head that far up my own arse to worry about grammer and puctuation
You also don't care about spelling. Perhaps you should try your own suggestion since your head doesn't seem to be much good for anything else.
my spelling is terrible,i have dyslexia,i was not handing in homework,try walking in my shoes before you judge.

NickBrt says...
9:20am Sun 9 Sep 12

ruberducker, none of the people I know with dyslexia claim it causes them to post inappropriate language the way it seems to do with you.
But let's get back to the issue, as HJarrs constantly tells us, Greens are the most wonderful people ever to walk the earth and can do no wrong. Please can we all have a statue of Jason and Caroline (and HJarrs) on every street corner.

Surely not! says...
10:05am Sun 9 Sep 12

NickBrt wrote:
ruberducker, none of the people I know with dyslexia claim it causes them to post inappropriate language the way it seems to do with you.
But let's get back to the issue, as HJarrs constantly tells us, Greens are the most wonderful people ever to walk the earth and can do no wrong. Please can we all have a statue of Jason and Caroline (and HJarrs) on every street corner.
Well I didn't vote Green last time, but I'm seriously considering it next time...certainly not the most wonderful people but no worse than the alternatives. They have done some good things made some mistakes. Of course if you know of a better place to put my cross I'd be interested to hear.

Valerie Paynter says...
11:21am Sun 9 Sep 12

Maxwell's Ghost wrote:
Recycling rates are low because this council refuses to deal with households who do not recycle including the 30,000 students in the community. Bags and bags of waste are piled up in student areas as the wheelie bins are full and the kids dont recycle and Cityclean just leave it outside houses while sticking silly 'oops' tape over boxes of recycling which accidentally get mixed up or a passerby drops a can in the bottle box of locals who do try to recycle. My neighbours have stopped recycling as the council don't bother getting everyone to do it. If a green administration cannot be bothered to tackle the basics such as recycling they can stuff their solar panels where the sun doesn't shine. As for all this carbon footprint targets a pointless waste of time when China, south America and other emerging economies are tearing the world apart by the hour. Breathe while you can. Your locally grown raspberries won't save us.
Once upon a time, this would have been a core Green target to focus on....but they 'widened' their appeal to include other issues that seem to have become very diverting for them - things like gay marriage and excising any Green Councillor not prepared to be corralled and controlled by every single issue, regardless of its hierarchical place, within the widened agenda.

I think it is time the Green Party made an hierarchical list of issues they have positions on and made it available to voters.

Same for all these political parties actually - slipping and sliding and weazling away at the public.

Valerie Paynter says...
11:26am Sun 9 Sep 12

Dirk Von Roden wrote:
the only thing the Greens have done is alienate car users and tourists ! they have created a permit only city for parking! they say that they will hold meetings to discuss parking meters in an area have they heck as like !! Albion st where although some folk park irresponsibly most are responsible they have installed meters with no consultation!! the greens are just out to ruin this city ! having a blue badge the cost does not really affect me but I do feel for those who have to pay through the nose for the chance of parking outside their own house!! just a thought but dont we pay rates and car tax for the use of the rd already????? so why should we buy a permit ! and the questionaire sent by B+H council have just sent out "TOO **** late " be as well using it for loo roll
Until such time as vehicle use becomes emissions-free, get used to ever deeper restrictions - especially as it means so much to health and actually being able to breathe and stay alive in cities.

I would personally provide every motorist (including the Green Party cllrs with their cars) a mileage allowance and penalties for exceeding it.

Only those using cars for work would be exempt.

And the mileage meter would be mounted on or within the vehicle and permanently available for inspection by parking attendants, police and for the annual MOT.

Shocked? Good. Makes the Greens look positively charitable on this front dunnit!

deanaprior says...
11:55am Sun 9 Sep 12

I understand the previous administration was planning to outsource as many services as it could so jobs and profits go elsewhere. I'm not particularly pro-green but just for this reason I will vote for them.

JumboJimbo says...
12:37pm Sun 9 Sep 12

Re:Allotments

>>>An increase of 116 allotment plots in the city during 2011/12

This is not 'new' allotments. This increase is only due to chopping plots in two. At the moment the policy is that every time an allotment becomes available, it is chopped into two allotments. That is how the greens are increasing allotment numbers.

That is why they have also sent out letters threatening termination to up to 80% of plot holders.. The letters say 'give up half your plot and the notice will be withdrawn.'

Many plot holders voted green thinking the Greens would save the allotment service from its terminal decline... in fact its turned out that the Greens have had the most damaging effect on allotments !

Dirk Von Roden says...
12:51pm Sun 9 Sep 12

Valerie I think if you do by chance come accross a brain cell you would be positively dangerous !! some folk need a car as they cant walk far ! it is folk like you that need composting!!!

HJarrs says...
3:00pm Sun 9 Sep 12

NickBrt wrote:
ruberducker, none of the people I know with dyslexia claim it causes them to post inappropriate language the way it seems to do with you. But let's get back to the issue, as HJarrs constantly tells us, Greens are the most wonderful people ever to walk the earth and can do no wrong. Please can we all have a statue of Jason and Caroline (and HJarrs) on every street corner.
Well, if the Greens are so bad then suggest why I should vote for anybody else? Name your party. I didn't expect miracles as I posted before, there have been sucesses and things that could have been done better but in the round I am happy with where I placed my vote.

I am pleased to live in a city where many local people have not followed the herd and unthinkingly voted for the main three political parties, but have got involved with and voted for something fresh and different. The Green Party is a local grass routes party, it is a shame you can't take some pride in this.

keswick says...
3:22pm Sun 9 Sep 12

gnarlychaos wrote:
Green party.This is your one shot. The next election will let you know just what local people think of you.Start packing now .
We live in hope that you are right.

george smith says...
4:08pm Sun 9 Sep 12

HJarrs wrote:
NickBrt wrote: ruberducker, none of the people I know with dyslexia claim it causes them to post inappropriate language the way it seems to do with you. But let's get back to the issue, as HJarrs constantly tells us, Greens are the most wonderful people ever to walk the earth and can do no wrong. Please can we all have a statue of Jason and Caroline (and HJarrs) on every street corner.
Well, if the Greens are so bad then suggest why I should vote for anybody else? Name your party. I didn't expect miracles as I posted before, there have been sucesses and things that could have been done better but in the round I am happy with where I placed my vote. I am pleased to live in a city where many local people have not followed the herd and unthinkingly voted for the main three political parties, but have got involved with and voted for something fresh and different. The Green Party is a local grass routes party, it is a shame you can't take some pride in this.
Different flock of sheep following mindlessly another idealogy

Valerie Paynter says...
4:24pm Sun 9 Sep 12

JumboJimbo wrote:
Re:Allotments >>>An increase of 116 allotment plots in the city during 2011/12 This is not 'new' allotments. This increase is only due to chopping plots in two. At the moment the policy is that every time an allotment becomes available, it is chopped into two allotments. That is how the greens are increasing allotment numbers. That is why they have also sent out letters threatening termination to up to 80% of plot holders.. The letters say 'give up half your plot and the notice will be withdrawn.' Many plot holders voted green thinking the Greens would save the allotment service from its terminal decline... in fact its turned out that the Greens have had the most damaging effect on allotments !
I'm told some full size plots are being chopped into quarter for re-allocation, that full-grown fruit trees are being ordered to be chopped down, etc., etc. which could not be more un-Green. Cruel too and causing huge distress to long-standing allotment-holders.

Valerie Paynter says...
4:29pm Sun 9 Sep 12

Dirk Von Roden wrote:
Valerie I think if you do by chance come accross a brain cell you would be positively dangerous !! some folk need a car as they cant walk far ! it is folk like you that need composting!!!
I stand corrected. I am one of those who can't walk freely any more and I use taxis or get driven where I need t go.

Your swaggering abuse makes you look a prat.

Somethingsarejustwrong says...
6:30pm Sun 9 Sep 12

And the Greens have achieved very little in my humble opinion, other than garner small pockets of support from people in minority groups who they seem happy to pander to.

Can't wait for the next elections when Brighton will surely vote them away.

Dirk Von Roden says...
6:37pm Sun 9 Sep 12

Valerie Paynter wrote:
Dirk Von Roden wrote:
Valerie I think if you do by chance come accross a brain cell you would be positively dangerous !! some folk need a car as they cant walk far ! it is folk like you that need composting!!!
I stand corrected. I am one of those who can't walk freely any more and I use taxis or get driven where I need t go.

Your swaggering abuse makes you look a prat.
aha so you get Taxis or driven !! if by your very silly statement folk were "rationed so to speak " re mileage would that taxi trip or car journey be included within your ration ? would the drivers mileage be inclusive ?? would you pay the extra cost for a taxi if a driver went over their"Allotted mileage"?? think dont just spout ! and as far as me looking a Pratt (TWO "T"s) I would rather look foolish in a comfortable car that gets me from a to b rather than looking like a Pratt when I cant make it any further in my wheelchair or fall over using my crutches!! so thank you Valerie for your very kind and well thought out response !! are you actually allowed out on your own??

Maxwell's Ghost says...
7:09pm Sun 9 Sep 12

Some of my media type, middle class friends admitted they voted Green for a change and have since said they will never do it again as they didn't recluse what a load of extremist student types were in the party.
It will be interesting to see if those comments in the round are true for many of the voters who tired of the mainstream parties only to find the Green folk are a smattering of right and left wingers who could sit in either the Tory or Labour groups.

HJarrs says...
8:09pm Sun 9 Sep 12

Maxwell's Ghost wrote:
Some of my media type, middle class friends admitted they voted Green for a change and have since said they will never do it again as they didn't recluse what a load of extremist student types were in the party. It will be interesting to see if those comments in the round are true for many of the voters who tired of the mainstream parties only to find the Green folk are a smattering of right and left wingers who could sit in either the Tory or Labour groups.
I think you will find I and many others would have a great deal of trouble sitting in the Tory or Labour groups as they simply represent a very narrow view of the world that doesn't address the pressing problems that we face in the long term. There is not a great deal to seperate them. True that the Tories are far more brutal, a Labour government would be preferable.

Rather it is many in the Labour and Liberal Parties that should find their natural home in the Green Party. But then politics is too tribal for some to change.

Roundbill says...
8:30pm Sun 9 Sep 12

I'm pretty certain this is the first comment thread I've ever read in the Argus, where TWO posters play the Cripple Card. I feel as if I've found a four-leaf clover.

ruberducker says...
8:47pm Sun 9 Sep 12

NickBrt wrote:
ruberducker, none of the people I know with dyslexia claim it causes them to post inappropriate language the way it seems to do with you.
But let's get back to the issue, as HJarrs constantly tells us, Greens are the most wonderful people ever to walk the earth and can do no wrong. Please can we all have a statue of Jason and Caroline (and HJarrs) on every street corner.
i never said it did,but lets get back to the issue,the greens have not done anything to make me re-elect them,and i stand by my remark....you have your head up your own arse thinking youre opinion is better just becuase you can spell it.

fredflintstone1 says...
12:56am Mon 10 Sep 12

Maxwell's Ghost wrote:
Some of my media type, middle class friends admitted they voted Green for a change and have since said they will never do it again as they didn't recluse what a load of extremist student types were in the party.
It will be interesting to see if those comments in the round are true for many of the voters who tired of the mainstream parties only to find the Green folk are a smattering of right and left wingers who could sit in either the Tory or Labour groups.
Act like students, voted in by students. A match made in heaven, except for the rest of the city which is suffering from the impact of these out-of-touch amateurs.

george smith says...
7:48am Mon 10 Sep 12

fredflintstone1 wrote:
Maxwell's Ghost wrote: Some of my media type, middle class friends admitted they voted Green for a change and have since said they will never do it again as they didn't recluse what a load of extremist student types were in the party. It will be interesting to see if those comments in the round are true for many of the voters who tired of the mainstream parties only to find the Green folk are a smattering of right and left wingers who could sit in either the Tory or Labour groups.
Act like students, voted in by students. A match made in heaven, except for the rest of the city which is suffering from the impact of these out-of-touch amateurs.
Interesting article on ecofascists
http://www.****.org
/texts/places/german
y/sp001630/peter.htm
l

Roundbill says...
3:46pm Mon 10 Sep 12

I think the nanny software may have beaten you, George.

Roundbill says...
3:49pm Mon 10 Sep 12

Try this link instead: takes you to the same place
http://tinyurl.com/5
zhco3

george smith says...
5:35pm Mon 10 Sep 12

Roundbill wrote:
Try this link instead: takes you to the same place http://tinyurl.com/5 zhco3
Thanks!

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree