Hove school ordered to dim its playing field lights after planning breach

Hove sports clubs have been forced to turn off the lights, just weeks after opening a new practice area.

Every week, hundreds of people use the £900,000 all-weather pitches at Blatchington Mill School in Nevill Close, Hove.

However, after complaints from neighbours about the lights breaching planning laws and streaming into their homes, they now must be turned off at 6.15pm every day.

It has meant Brighton and Hove Hockey Club (BHHC), which shares the facilities with the school and other sports teams, has had to cancel training at the site for the foreseeable future.

One resident, who asked not to be named, said: “It has been horrendous. The glare from some of the floodlights is such that even with the curtains closed, we’re blinded by them.

“We’re not anti-school, anti-hockey or anti-sport. It’s just too large a development for the site.”

Planning permission for the development was granted by the local authority in August 2011. About 360 people supported the plans, which were backed by Hockey England, and 120 opposed them.

The 12 floodlights, which are each 60ft high and dotted around the pitches, are about 60 metres away from about 40 properties in Nevill Avenue and Holmes Avenue.

After the pitches were opened in September, the first complaints were received by the council days later. The school has now been told it is breaching two planning conditions about the brightness and visibility of the bulbs.

The voluntary ban was enforced from yesterday but if the school operates outside of this time, the local authority said it would start formal enforcement action.

Ward councillor Dawn Barnett said: “It’s worse than Blackpool seafront. I’m hoping it will be sorted as quickly as possible as the council has taken far too long in acting on this.”

Cameron Heath, a BHHC development officer, said he had only been informed of the issue on Friday and engineers were on site yesterday trying to sort out the problem.

Training had been cancelled but some of the senior sides were looking for alternative venues in the short term.

Mr Heath said: “It certainly was not our intention to inconvenience anybody or disrupt anybody’s lives.

“It’s a balance between making sure the light levels are safe on the pitch and limiting the spill beyond it.

“We have acted as quickly as we can. Once we have the engineers’ test report we can send it the council and hopefully lift the ban.”

In a letter to residents, the local authority said: “The school have agreed to carry out the necessary works to ensure these conditions were complied with as soon as possible.”

Comments(11)

pwlr1966 says...
3:24pm Tue 16 Oct 12

What a shame that hundreds of children will be forced back onto the streets to play football abd hockey because of a few nimbies. If you live next to a school you should expect this sort of thing

dommer2000 says...
3:59pm Tue 16 Oct 12

Bit of a slow response, pwlr1966 - over an hour and a half to turn off Jeremy Kyle, put down your copy of the daily mail and churn out the standard "Nimby" phrase (although try and spell it right next time). If you tell me where you live, I'll come and shine 12 2000 watt floodlights directly into your house and see how you like it. The problem isn't with the "nimbies" but with the cretinous planners who designed the things wrong in the first place, but that may already be too much information for you to process.

aat99 says...
4:03pm Tue 16 Oct 12

Dommer 2000 ... so all 12 floodlights are directly pointing into your house .... strange !

pwlr1966 says...
4:38pm Tue 16 Oct 12

dommer2000 wrote:
Bit of a slow response, pwlr1966 - over an hour and a half to turn off Jeremy Kyle, put down your copy of the daily mail and churn out the standard "Nimby" phrase (although try and spell it right next time). If you tell me where you live, I'll come and shine 12 2000 watt floodlights directly into your house and see how you like it. The problem isn't with the "nimbies" but with the cretinous planners who designed the things wrong in the first place, but that may already be too much information for you to process.
FYI I don't read the Mail or watch Kyle, but I do know planners plan things and designers design things two very different professions.

I do hope you don't have too much anti social behavior around your streets in the near future, what with those pesky trick and treaters and nowhere for them to play

John Fallon says...
5:43pm Tue 16 Oct 12

There was the same problem with Yellowave when that started and its floodlights affected homes on Marine Parade. That was all amicably resolved with the floodlight angle changed and a few baffles installed. The same result should be possible at the playing fields, so everyone will be happy.

Hove Actually says...
5:53pm Tue 16 Oct 12

pwlr1966 wrote:
What a shame that hundreds of children will be forced back onto the streets to play football abd hockey because of a few nimbies. If you live next to a school you should expect this sort of thing
You silly silly boy.....
First these neighbours then, those near the cricket ground, then near the Stations, then near anywhere.

Planning rules are there to protect everyone not just those affected today

pwlr1966 says...
6:59pm Tue 16 Oct 12

Firstly, i live next to the school and overlook the playing fields, yes the lights are bright but they are turned off by 9pm but I can live with that, they are not as bad as others have made out. I would rather see children playing in a safe and controlled environment than roaming the streets.

Secondly planning permission was applied for & granted by the council, therefor the work was carried out under their controls. If anyone is at fault it is them.

Thirdly i am neither silly nor a boy but i might be a pedant!

bogs says...
8:13pm Tue 16 Oct 12

I don't want to be named, but it's teen really bad! I have asked God to make the sun set earlier, because it shines through my windows, but He just won't listen..............
.

george smith says...
7:28am Wed 17 Oct 12

Having to endure the noise from the kids all day and the parents blocking the roads with their cars, should they really expected to have to then contend with light pollution. If my memory serves me, I seem to recall a hockey club tried to have a floodlt pitch on the surrendean campus and the local residents fought against it.

Noah Lott says...
8:39am Wed 17 Oct 12

How, in an age where we can simulate lighting schemes prior to their installation, has this happened? When designing the lighting scheme, surely someone provided details on it prior to its installation so that the Lux levels and any light pollution to the surrounding areas could be properly assessed?! I've designed large external lighting schemes for Clients in the past - sports pitches, car parks, pedestrian routes, etc. - and on every occasion provided design documents for approval by the client. If this has been the case here, then whatever dimwit approved the scheme should consider their position as I don't think they're up to the job. If it turns out to be as a result of poor design, then I would hope the designer has sufficient PI insurance!

BradleyWiggins says...
9:21am Wed 17 Oct 12

NIMBY-ism gone phuqing mad! If you look at other European countries they have floodlight sport facilities open until 10pm at night in residential areas.

If you dont like the light - close your curtains or at least enjoy the "free" lighting for your homes and gardens. You live near a school playing field/sports centre - get over it or move!

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree