News RSS Feed


Comment and Analysis

Parking charges are the last straw for strugging Brighton traders


Motorists have already criticised Brighton and Hove City Council for its plans to raise car parking charges once again.

But traders are also unhappy about the increase, which is due in April, and say they, too, will be penalised as the higher charges drive shoppers away from the city.

Last year, the council made a £7.4 million profit from motorists.

Yet, in April, the parking tariffs are expected to increase again, adding £320,000 to next year’s council budget.

Harm

The charges were increased in March last year and Brighton and Hove already has the highest parking costs outside of London.

Stuart Wilkie, who owns children’s toy shop Charlie Barley in Meeting House Lane and is the spokesman for the Lanes Business Network, said raising the parking charges again would do traders more harmthan good.

He said: “We were under the impression that this administration was looking at a complementary transport system.

“Clearly, that’s not happening because the motorist is being penalised.

“Anything which stops people coming into town, or which stops business and trade, is a bad thing.

“Raising parking charges is something else that does that.

“The council’s timing, considering the economic uncertainty, is not fair.”

The latest rise will see the price of short-term stays of up to two hours increase in two of the four council-run car parks in the city centre.

The car park that will be most affected is London Road, which has recently been refurbished.

Resident permits, on-street pay-and-display and seafront parking spaces will also have their tariffs increased.

For traders in London Road and North Laine the rise in car parking charges is not at all welcome news.

Sharon Thomas, chairwoman of the North Laine Traders’ Association, said the price hike would put people off coming into the city centre, while Christina Summers, from the Another London Road campaign, which is working to revitalise the area, said the workers would be most affected.

She added: “More people will seek out the free parking roads, which are already at saturation point.

Residents find it difficult to find a place to park.”

Mr Wilkie said it was difficult to gauge how rises in parking charges would affect footfall because people still parked their cars in Churchill Square and walked down into The Lanes.

But he added that the increase in parking tariffs would change people’s shopping habits.

He said: “It will make people think twice about coming into Brighton in the first place.

“I had a customer who came in last weekend who had last been in the shop in August.

As she left she said, ‘I will see you in six months, probably in the summer’.

“I told her she didn’t have to leave it so long but she said the hassle and expense of parking meant she avoided coming into Brighton so often.

“The amount of money people spend on parking, before they even start to shop, takes the pleasure out of visiting the city.”

Mr Wilkie said the snow and ice meant January had been a bad month for traders because people could not get into the city centre safely.

He added: “Nothing was done to compensate that.

“Whatever the council can do to encourage more trade into the city this year needs to be done.

“This year, a lot more people are considering spending their holiday in Britain.

If they come to Sussex, get in their cars and drive to Brighton, which we want them to do, it should be encouraged by regulating parking charges.

Balance

“The council makes so much money through parking.

“It really has got to balance what it does and give reasons for why it is charging so much.

“I do not think we have seen the results of the investment from the money it has made out of car parking.

“People would probably be more responsive if they didn’t just see it as a cash cow.”

Click here for a full list of the parking charge changes


Your Say YourArgus

Luke72, Hove says...
11:51am Mon 8 Feb 10

Why are residents' permits so expensive? I can see the logic in charging a higher by the hour price to reduce people driving into the centre of town but the only reason for higher residents' permits costs is to generate income. I've made it clear to my local councillors I consider this an important issue for the next local election.

Nyberg, Ystad says...
12:10pm Mon 8 Feb 10

I went to a concert at the Dome last night, and couldn't find a free space, so had to use the NCP Theatre car park.
I was parked just over 2 hours. Parking fee was NINE POUNDS!!
RIP OFF BRIGHTON. You wouldn't pay that much in central London.
The bus for two people would have only been £2 less, but one would have had to hang around, and very likely share the bus with a drunk or two, so the car was the only reasonable option.
I can't believe they are allowed to get away with it.

ArthurD, Horsham says...
8:42pm Mon 8 Feb 10

Removing the 3 hour payment band in some of the car parks is just sheer pettiness. I don't mind the charges rising a little though.

Especially paying in advance, no one wants to risk overstaying and 2 hours is barely enough for most purposes, 3 hours is often ideal.

Extending the time band to 8 pm will also mean evening parking in Norton Road (when the car park is almost deserted anyway) will become chargeable.

The earlier start time for charging will make it harder to stay in Brighton/Hove overnight without having to get up early to avoid a ticket - removing the attraction of staying in a hotel after a night out.

Surely this cannot help local trade?

Living in the real world, Brighton says...
11:04pm Mon 8 Feb 10

They dont care, the car driver is a soft easy target who they do not have to drag through the court to maybe get a fine from at a later date. He is a cash cow they cannot stop milking just because they can.

My friends and family drive to Shoreham for a meal out now as they have free parking and great resturantsand the prices are better

Rastus Watermelon, Brighton says...
1:22am Tue 9 Feb 10

By the way, it's spelt "struggling" - headline reads:
"Parking charges are the last straw for strugging Brighton traders"

D Merrett, East Sussex says...
12:57pm Tue 9 Feb 10

I feel sorry for the smaller traders as Brighton and Hove is really "shut for business" . The council are hell-bent on destroying the City. However, you really do have more power than you think, and I think you have got to take this problem home to the council. Block off all car-parks where council officers park. Hand out leaflets at the town halls, and maybe stop them coming to work.

fatboyjim, brighton says...
10:16pm Wed 10 Feb 10

Residents permits are scam. I waited a year, paid £100 and now they've made a big chunk of my road 'pay and display' and removed the zone letter from the sign so its no longer covered by my permit.

The Good Driver, Zog says...
1:55pm Thu 11 Feb 10

Highest parking costs outside of London? In England? Britain? Europe? The World?

I avoid Brighton for any form of shopping, if possible. We have a meal in town sometimes when I can park a bit later in the evening for nothing.

Obviously, a city needs to generate income, but the charges in Brighton are prohibitive.

The fall-back argument from the authorities is, of course, that they are trying to cut the amount of traffic coming into the city. Aided by scrapping the park-and-ride at Withdean.

hawksmoor, Brighton says...
2:40pm Thu 11 Feb 10

Whine, whine, whine. Get it through your think petrol headed skulls, motorists who come into town are a self indulgent minority. They ruin the city for the great majority who come into town on foot, bike, train or bus. Resident's parking permits are ludicrously cheap. If you want to own a car in the city centre it is your responsibility to accommodate it, not the Council's. Go look for long term private parking and you'll find the parking permit is very cheap. Too cheap. Every time I hear another Jeremy Clarkson clone say they won't come into Brighton as it is so expensive to park I think we're making some small progress.

Gubbins, Worthing says...
9:01am Fri 12 Feb 10

The sad truth is, big cities cost big bucks to run and it can only get worse as this recession bites deeper over the next few years.

Massive cuts in Council expenditure are the only answer and traders will have to diversify their marketing and sales techniques.

There are no easy answers, those who are not willing to be part of the solution, will remain part of the problem.

namgo49, bognor regis says...
8:05pm Sat 13 Feb 10

Stay at home, shop via the internet, it's more environmentally friendly. We fill our lives with going shopping and boozing because our lives are so shallow we can't think of anything better to do.

Spreadly, Brighton says...
12:59am Sun 14 Feb 10

I live in Brighton, own 3 cars and shop on line. Perfect.

Old Ladys Gin, Shoreham says...
7:21am Mon 15 Feb 10

namgo49 wrote:
Stay at home, shop via the internet, it's more environmentally friendly. We fill our lives with going shopping and boozing because our lives are so shallow we can't think of anything better to do.
And staying at home, shopping on the internet isn't shallow?
Life is on the streets, out there with the noise and bustle.

Comments are closed on this article.


Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »