News RSS Feed


Blog: Follow your leader - Brighton Pavilion.

They won't let me in! They won't let me in!

The presenters of News night, the Politics show and whatever lame coverage Meridian are dishing up, would like you to believe that the constituency of Brighton Pavilion is that rare and newsworthy event, a 4 way marginal. Now this isn't something that happens just off the main drag in Phuket, what the media are implying is that basically Pavilion, is a 4 horse political race.

Let me tell you now, its not. As much as I admire Bernie Millam (Lib Dem) and the lovely Nancy Platts (Labour) Pav (as we call it in these parts)appears to be a straight fight between the delectable Tory candidate Charlotte Vere, and the Glenda Jackson esque, Green Party leader Caroline Lucas.

In a normal City, and I say that as 5th generation Brightonian, it is very likely Vere given the general apathy towards the government, would be looking forward, without too much doubt to a generous majority. However Brighton's infamous diversity, ensures that the Greens appear to have pockets of support, in the more shall we say, trendy area's of the city.

In Hanover, the New England quarter and Preston Circus you will, if you wander for a while , note more than the odd Green poster or even flag proclaiming that you should 'Vote Lucas'.

However, the above captioned locales of central Brighton, have always been the most likely to harbour the type of dormant socialist the Greens are hoping mark their card.

Having read the Green manifesto it is clear that their policies are more far reaching than what many consider they might be. If you ask the average Brighton man on the street what he thinks the Greens philosophy is, he will no doubt respond that pollution, recycling and carbon emissions are the pivotal points of the Green party agenda.

If you dare to look more closely at the Green Party manifesto you may be shocked to realize they are in fact far more radical than that. They plan to increase petrol to £1.45 a litre and set a speed limit of 55 mph to our motorways. Corporation tax would be increased by 2% possibly costing thousands of jobs, as would imposing a strict 35 hour week. They will impose an aviation fuel duty, which would likely increase the cost of air travel and at the tax payers expense provide free school meals for ALL school children. Not to mention leaving NATO and abolishing trident. But the most radical and ludicrous Green policy is the suggestion of a congestion charge for Brighton. The seafront traders will love that one.

So why this support for Dr Lucas'? It is surely tribal voting or in this case tribal support, that may manifest into tribal voting. Brighton is the migration capital of the south, perhaps of whole country. It is apparently the place to be. Many of us remember fondly when Brighton was a quite seedy, run down, unfashionable place to be. Famed only for ships that run aground, and cup final thrashings. (replays only) Nowadays it is consider the uber cultural capital of the world. When in fact it is living way in excess of its trendy reputation. Some who are only temporary interlopers who have who have headed south in the same tribal way they may vote on May 6th, are the very reason Dr Lucas chose Brighton, especially Pavilion, for her assault to gain a parliamentary seat.

If Caroline Lucas does become the right honourable member, her victory will not be indicative of the opinion of many of the established Brightonians. Those that were born here and may very well die here. Those that would like to see sensible politics from a sensible politician.

A Green vote will not change the political picture in Britain. I doubt any of their policies will be implemented, so a vote for them is much like putting unleaded in a diesel engine, just because it might be a couple of pence cheaper!

Green voters will be influenced by other Green voters, irrespective of the contents of that manifesto. Voting Green is chance to be seen to be trendy, to be different.Or perhaps be misled, and sadly on many counts to be misinformed and somewhat ignorant of the basic facts.

Brighton people may be green, surely they're not cabbage looking.

Comments(9)

andyjm says...
4:13pm Wed 5 May 10

so who is this guy? an argus journo? is this the argus editorial line? are there similarly biased pieces by supporters/haters of other parties coming in the next 12 hours??

the day before the election! very very poor show, whatever your politics...

joe9 says...
4:49pm Wed 5 May 10

This is very disappointing from the Argus. I don't mind a partisan writer, but your reasoning is dreadful and the whole argument is pinned on inconsistencies and shoddy stereotypes. I'm no 'tribal' interloper, I'll be voting green for the first time - not to be trendy, but because I believe that it's right. I have read their whole manifesto - and while I don't agree with everything in it, there are many good progressive policies. And who does agree with any party's whole manifesto? I care more about our air quality and our health than about what the seafront traders thinkof a congestion charge - they are a minority in this city. Lucas would be MP, not our council leader, so it's unclear just how she'd enforce that policy. Also, as she'd be first green MP, no-one rational would suggest that the green manifesto will be implemented during the next government. But she would have an important symbolic impact - she would draw much needed attention to the real changes needed to make government policies more sustainable.
Let's see some balanced writing for a change please. You can do better than this - can't you?

Gaz the great says...
6:11pm Wed 5 May 10

Sorry folks but agree with the Argus reporter, the Greens would destroy this country with their deranged views!

keeshond8 says...
7:20pm Wed 5 May 10

Has this journalist actually listened to the views of Charlotte (de) Vere whom he seems to be supporting? There are plenty of other seaside towns like Worthing where her Thatcherite agenda would be more appropriate - seedy, rundown and unfashionable, which presumably describes Tim Hodges's natural habitat. From just looking at his photo, I feel he would be happiest sounding off in a saloon bar somewhere, crying into his third pint of the yellow stuff after Miss Vere's defeat on his beloved home soil.

Thumper Hove says...
8:18pm Wed 5 May 10

How much was the Argus paid by the Green Party for this free publicity/advert.

If electorate was to pay for the Green Party's ludicrous taxation and loony policies then no-one would vote for them. She is only a token politician and an excuse for hippies and those on the dole to think they are being radical and different by voting for her.

imyourboss says...
1:04pm Thu 6 May 10

Blog or angry, right wing posting? Why is the Argus promoting such narrow minded, biased cant? The Argus needs to seriously think about putting ramblings like this up, unless they're happy with his skewed views.

Murgatroyd says...
1:17pm Thu 6 May 10

The entire content seems to be lifted from the tacky, poison-pen-letter style, badly produced, sensationalised anti-Green 2 sides of A4 posted through my letterbox last week. You had to look really, really hard to see where it had come from - but there, in tiny print, at the bottom it was. Charlotte Vere.

RoddyG says...
2:40pm Thu 6 May 10

One of the best written and most accurate accounts of the General Election in Brighton Pavilion. The vast majority of people intending to Vote for (Dr?) Lucas have been hoodwinked by her army of unwashed marxist followers. Don't vote Green!

Murgatroyd says...
3:36pm Thu 6 May 10

RoddyG wrote:
One of the best written and most accurate accounts of the General Election in Brighton Pavilion. The vast majority of people intending to Vote for (Dr?) Lucas have been hoodwinked by her army of unwashed marxist followers. Don't vote Green!
It was only a matter of time before somebody pitched in with a stupid comment about personal hygiene and green politics. If the only thing that tories can resort to is personal insults then they must be feeling pretty desperate

click2find

Most popular






About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree