News RSS Feed


Wedding DVD disaster

2:09pm Monday 24th September 2007

comment Comments (11)   Have your say »

By Jess Bauldry »

Staff at a register office have let down a second couple by losing their wedding DVD.

Carl and Ruth Carter-Hale were looking forward to receiving a DVD copy of their civil wedding ceremony at Brighton Town Hall to show to relatives who missed the service.

They were horrified when they found out their copy, recorded by Town Hall staff, had been lost in the post and the original had been wiped.

The couple contacted The Argus after they read about Shaun and Anzhela Stewart, from Bexhill, who were sent the DVD of another couple's wedding.

They only discovered the blunder while visiting relatives in the Ukraine. By the time they returned to complain the original footage had been wiped.

Mrs Carter-Hale, 27, of Westfield Crescent, Hollingbury, Brighton, said: "We were shocked to know it had happened to other couples too. It's horrifying really."

The couple married on July 28 before spending their honeymoon on the Isle of Wight.

Mr Carter-Hale, 35, who is off work on long-term sick leave, said: "Because we didn't know how long the process would take we weren't surprised it hadn't arrived when we got back off our honeymoon.

"We didn't want to appear pushy so we thought we would let them get on with it for a while.

"We left it a couple of weeks and when we called back we found out it had been sent out first class in the post on July 30. But we hadn't received it.

"We asked if they could make another copy but they said the person responsible was on holiday and said they would get back to us."

At the end of August the couple spoke to the Town Hall's wedding DVD co-ordinator. She had not received the message and had wiped the film off the system.

Unlike the Stewarts, who had no wedding mementoes, the Carter-Hales made sure they had photographs of their special day.

But because Mrs Carter-Hale has limited short-term memory as a result of a brain tumour she suffered as a teenager, she cannot remember much of the ceremony.

She said: "We've got photos but it doesn't put anything in context. I can't remember the ceremony or the vows. It's just a blur.

"But that was not why we wanted the DVD. We had a lot of family who couldn't make it to the service because of illness who were relying on seeing the film.

"I think it's pretty awful. I'm angry the message that our DVD was missing wasn't passed on.

"I'm astonished they send the films out and they don't consider people are on their honeymoons. You should be able to collect them.

"I would like to see them change their policy so they check with couples before they delete copies. People should also have an option how they receive their film. They could collect it in person or get it posted after a certain date.

"I just don't want this to happen to anyone else."

A Brighton and Hove City Council spokeswoman said: "We apologise that Mr and Mrs Carter-Hale did not receive their DVD copy.

"Our advice is that if couples do not receive their DVDs within two weeks or if something is wrong with it, to contact us for another copy and we will be happy to provide one.

"Currently we are unable to keep the DVDs on file for more than a month, but as this service is becoming increasingly popular we are looking into extending the computer memory so that the register office can keep DVDs on our records for longer."

Has your wedding DVD been lost? Or have you had a wedding day disaster? Tell us below.


Your Say YourArgus

Rick, Brighton says...
2:34pm Mon 24 Sep 07

Annoying. Irritating. Slightly upsetting. Yes.

But "horrifying"? I think not.

LB, Hove says...
3:06pm Mon 24 Sep 07

Would it be beyond the councils capability to take a second copy of the dvd before postage and keep it somewhere safe?

Then they wouldn't need to organise extra online storage at whatever expense, just a cupboard.

The other alternative is just to include a form for people to return/ phone them to make sure they'd got the dvd before deleting the master.

Either way, problem solved at minimal public expense.

emma, hove says...
4:45pm Mon 24 Sep 07

i take it your not married Rick, idiot

Gino, Hanover says...
4:48pm Mon 24 Sep 07

An extra DVD would cost 50p, so I can see why the council is unable to pick up such a huge overhead.

A 250 gigabyte external hard drive could cost nearly £100 pounds.

They could always charge the couple £1 to cover the cost of two DVD's!

It's really tricky and expensive isn't it, there’s no way they could have prevented it happening twice.

I look forward to reading about the third loss shortly.

Boring, CHEAPSKATE WEDDINGS says...
5:03pm Mon 24 Sep 07

Gino wrote:
An extra DVD would cost 50p, so I can see why the council is unable to pick up such a huge overhead.

A 250 gigabyte external hard drive could cost nearly £100 pounds.

They could always charge the couple £1 to cover the cost of two DVD's!

It's really tricky and expensive isn't it, there’s no way they could have prevented it happening twice.

I look forward to reading about the third loss shortly.
a 250gb external hard drive would cost about £60. or a 400gb from PCWorld is currently £79.99?

jo, haywards heath says...
7:39pm Mon 24 Sep 07

Oh Emma of Hove, get a life. Rick is quite right saying it's not horrifying. God help you if anything terrible happens to you or family, then you'll know what horrifying is. Losing a DVD isn't! Though probably in Emma's perfect world, Emma is the only person that exists/matters. And yes, i am married and very happily so to someone who lives in the real world thankfully.

Rick, Brighon says...
10:33am Tue 25 Sep 07

I'll be getting married next year. Without a video, which would probably only be watched once then brought out again 40 years later. Mind you, you probably won't be able to play DVDs in 40 years.

I bet the people who spent £500 on a VHS wedding video in 1985 are gutted now...

bob, lewes says...
11:17am Tue 25 Sep 07

Silly on the councils part, doesnt exactly need a complex system or expense to ensure this doesnt happen..

Its the experience and memories that really count, I feel wedding videos can sometimes be a bit naff, aprt from the one where I did an excellent best mans speech that is :-)

Leah, Brighton says...
1:18pm Tue 25 Sep 07

If you want something done its always best to do it yourself.. That way you cant blame other people when it goes wrong. They could have borrowed a video recorder if it was that important!!!

Paul, Brighton Seafront says...
2:20pm Tue 25 Sep 07

Leah wrote:
If you want something done its always best to do it yourself.. That way you cant blame other people when it goes wrong. They could have borrowed a video recorder if it was that important!!!
I am not sure how that would work. Both the Bride and Groom would need to have their hands free to exchange rings and so on. Holidng a camcorder would overly complicate matters.

I think Jo's husband might contest whether they are happily married. One little comment by Emma and she has a vein popping out from her forehead. It is pretty clear as to who wears the trousers over in Haywards Heath!

Rick, Brighton says...
4:34pm Tue 25 Sep 07

Just seems to me another symptom of people who are more hung up on the trappings of the day, than the actual act of marriage itself.

Your sayYourArgus

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE The Argus account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?
Ruth and Carl Carter-Hale Ruth and Carl Carter-Hale

Sponsored Links


Local Services


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »