News RSS Feed


Brighton band rejected Leona

12:26pm Thursday 25th October 2007

comment Comments (24)   Have your say »

By Simon Barrett »

When Leona Lewis won The X Factor and a £1milllion recording contract, members of Brighton band Silent Earth didn't know whether to laugh or cry.

Because just a few months earlier the talented singer was rejected after auditioning to be their new vocalist.

Leona - who looks set to have the fastest-selling single of 2007 with Bleeding Love - was one of 500 people aiming to replace singer Una Creary, last year.

Leona was called back and then asked to record a demo of their track Times Have Changed, written by Ru Garvey and Dan Karrouze.

Her soulful voice blew the pair away and they were keen for Leona to join their bid to become the next big thing out of Brighton, following the likes of The Kooks and Fatboy Slim.

But then ex-bandmate Una threw a spanner in the works by demanding to rejoin the band, and the next time they saw Leona she was on X Factor.

Dan, 39, who lives in East Preston, near Littlehampton, said: "Leona came down to the studio and she was amazing. We got on really well and it was obvious how much talent she had.

"But we turned her down to take Una back, which was a huge mistake because she left again, and we are still looking for a vocalist.

"The worst thing was Leona said she was entering X Factor and I told her it would ruin her career if she wanted to be taken seriously as a singer. I think it was the last thing I said to her - it makes me look like a right doughnut!"

Silent Earth began when Dan and Ru, from Brighton, met three years ago. Dan had been producing tracks for a while when he sought a co-producer to help create the mellow dance and ambient soul sound he had envisaged.

Through a chance meeting they got chatting about music and the band was formed with long time friends Jonny Maiden and Matthew Wear.

Between them the band have worked with the likes of Barry White and Amy Winehouse, and their album FAQ came out this year.

Dan added: "Despite kicking ourselves we were really pleased for Leona when she won, and if she still fancies joining the band she is more than welcome.

"We are still looking for the right vocalist and will be holding auditions soon. We'd love to get that search televised or broadcast on the internet - maybe we'll unearth another gem like Leona."

Find out more about the band by visiting www.silentearth.co.uk .

Click here to listen to the demo of Times Have Changed


Your Say YourArgus

Dave, Hove says...
12:58pm Thu 25 Oct 07

shows how tone deaf Silent Earth are then. Cant wait to see them live......NOT!! No doubt they will now thrive off the back of being tone deaf!

Butcher, 806-550 says...
1:22pm Thu 25 Oct 07

More fool silent Earth! Not really there style though, I know that these guys are absolute talentless dirt bags. Give up guys your rap with a capital C missing.

Sammy Davis Jnr, Brighton says...
2:29pm Thu 25 Oct 07

Leona who??????????

joe 90, hove says...
2:55pm Thu 25 Oct 07

Yes I was quite shocked to hear this news as well...when I read it in the Sun newspaper this morning.

mrs, sussex says...
3:33pm Thu 25 Oct 07

Leona is brilliant, she will go far, and hopefully stay grounded. Silent earth see the grass in not always greener on the other side.

Roger, Brighton says...
3:45pm Thu 25 Oct 07

Why, when the group have been gracious enough to admit their error and wish Leona well, does everybody feel the need to sneer at them? Can't you appreciate good manners, when it's there for all to see, anymore?

paul, Brighton says...
4:02pm Thu 25 Oct 07

Silent Death..... oops, sorry, Earth... who??????????

Sammy Davis Jnr, Brighton says...
4:10pm Thu 25 Oct 07

Leona Lewis will go the way of all other X Factor, Britain's Got Talent and whatever the other rubbish 'let's pick a superstar out from Joe Public' reality shows that swamp our weekend television viewing. This time next year her CD will be in the Woolworth's clearance bin at 99p once her 15 minutes of fame has gone.
Hearsay anyone.....?

rob, hove says...
4:14pm Thu 25 Oct 07

joe 90 wrote:
Yes I was quite shocked to hear this news as well...when I read it in the Sun newspaper this morning.
Yes incredible, the same story in TWO newspapers. What a worthy comment. Maybe you should become a full time media commentator Joe.

S. Cowell, Studio says...
4:17pm Thu 25 Oct 07

Sammy Davis Jnr wrote:
Leona Lewis will go the way of all other X Factor, Britain's Got Talent and whatever the other rubbish 'let's pick a superstar out from Joe Public' reality shows that swamp our weekend television viewing. This time next year her CD will be in the Woolworth's clearance bin at 99p once her 15 minutes of fame has gone. Hearsay anyone.....?
Cheer up, Sammy.

Lemar, Girls Aloud, Will Young, Liberty (X) anyone?

Dave, Hove says...
4:21pm Thu 25 Oct 07

Sammy Davis Jnr wrote:
Leona Lewis will go the way of all other X Factor, Britain\'s Got Talent and whatever the other rubbish \'let\'s pick a superstar out from Joe Public\' reality shows that swamp our weekend television viewing. This time next year her CD will be in the Woolworth\'s clearance bin at 99p once her 15 minutes of fame has gone. Hearsay anyone.....?
Gareth Gates, Chico, not forgetting the fat one her names rhymes with a-nus

mrs, sussex says...
4:33pm Thu 25 Oct 07

Well Sammy Davis Junior, Leona Lewis has already cracked America which i don't think any other x factor winner has achieved. Have a little faith and give the girl some credit.

Sammy Davis Jnr, Brighton says...
4:59pm Thu 25 Oct 07

mrs wrote:
Well Sammy Davis Junior, Leona Lewis has already cracked America which i don't think any other x factor winner has achieved. Have a little faith and give the girl some credit.
No!

What a, JOKE! says...
5:01pm Thu 25 Oct 07

This band trying to promote themselves through a mistake? not the way to get signed or noticed! fame hungry, talentless artists (mark ronson, for example) are all the same.

Fiona and Sara, Brighton says...
7:08pm Thu 25 Oct 07

We would be happy to join you as we are available at the moment and we are already quite well known. You don't need Leona, you'll thank us in the end.

hello, goodbye says...
1:48am Fri 26 Oct 07








bumfinger












( its a private 'silent earth' joke ..rest of you peasants wouldnt understand our genius )

mrs, sussex says...
8:53am Fri 26 Oct 07

Sammy Davis Jnr wrote:
mrs wrote: Well Sammy Davis Junior, Leona Lewis has already cracked America which i don\'t think any other x factor winner has achieved. Have a little faith and give the girl some credit.
No!
god there are some miserable people around.

Dufus, Brighton says...
10:20am Fri 26 Oct 07

Fiona and Sara are probably about to enroll on a Glaxo Drug trial - so should be in great shape for being band members.

KH, says...
10:31am Fri 26 Oct 07

I think its Fab that there are still honest people around - and by-the-way Silent Earth's music is Fantastic!!!!

No, They are RUBBISH says...
10:34am Fri 26 Oct 07

KH wrote:
I think its Fab that there are still honest people around - and by-the-way Silent Earth's music is Fantastic!!!!
liar - you must be their mum or actually in the band! they suck!

jim, western australia says...
11:51am Fri 26 Oct 07

Good to see a local make good. The band are happy for the success, why shouldn't we.

regards

Jim

Kel, Hove says...
12:39pm Fri 26 Oct 07

What a wrote:
This band trying to promote themselves through a mistake? not the way to get signed or noticed! fame hungry, talentless artists (mark ronson, for example) are all the same.
Thank god someone else can see right through them!!!!

mither, hove says...
12:08am Sat 27 Oct 07

they may be deaf but some of you are blind did you not read the story - they thought she was fantastic but the other lead singer bulldozed her way back - durrr

Durrr, Brighton says...
9:05am Mon 29 Oct 07

Some of you should learn to not believe everything you read in the papers...!!!

Your sayYourArgus

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE The Argus account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?
Silent Earth Silent Earth

Sponsored Links


Local Services


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »