How the Brighton and Hove parking debate landed me with a £25 fine

Tim looks fed up after receiving a parking ticket Tim looks fed up after receiving a parking ticket

In nearly four years living in Brighton and Hove I thought I had done it all – swam in the winter sea, inscribed my name on a pebble on the beach and lost a chip to a seagull.

But something happened to me last week which meant I had well and truly been there, done that and got the T-shirt (with a commemorative stick of rock thrown in) – my first parking ticket.

In a city where parking is king and where even those waiting for the bus moan about how expensive it is to leave their cars anywhere, it has been a minor miracle it has taken this long.

Let us be clear – it was not a major offence. I was just unlucky that a council meeting I was attending overran and I did not have the change to pay for another ticket.

The irony of all ironies was that it came at a meeting where, in part, parking income was being discussed.

But, hey ho, I’m not directing blame at anyone. It would be easy to blame the politicians who spent far too long talking.

It would be easy to criticise the traffic warden – sorry, civil enforcement officer – who issued the ticket and throw four-letter expletives in his direction. It could also quite feasibly be easy to blame the car for not moving itself.

But I’m not going to do that – and I’m definitely not going to send the fine to council leader Jason Kitcat asking for a rebate on the grounds a meeting he was overseeing overran.

The fault well and truly rests at my feet, which should have been on the accelerator pedal rather than under a table in Hove Town Hall.

Yet, this does not mean I will take the punishment lying down.

For far too long now, parking in Brighton and Hove has been an expensive necessity.

Then the Green council administration decided to carry out a widespread review and hike city centre charges to £3.50 for the shortest possible stay, an hour. For an update on the long-running saga you just have to read the pages of the Argus. 

But it got me thinking – what happens if there is a full scale revolt?

I for one – and I don’t think I’m the only one – have simply not been paying for parking on some occasions. Why should I pay £3.50 when all I need to do is pop into a shop for five minutes and pick up a paper?

Is it not worth it in the long run to risk leaving your car in a legal spot and just pay the £25 fine if the parking gestapo catch up with you?

What would happen if we all did it? The council doesnt have the number of wardens on the street to inspect every car, wait the statutory five minutes and issue it with a ticket.

Let’s say there are 50 wardens – sorry, civil enforcement officers – working on a particular day, that’s a maximum of 600 tickets an hour or 4,500 over a working day. Can the council really process that many fines in a working day?

Within weeks I can guarantee there would be a reduction in some of the tariffs, in part to ease the workload from staff but also because of the mass damage to the council's parking income. It certainly would be a lot more effective than shouting abuse at a warden.

But then again, I’ll probably just cough up the cash, have a moan and next time use the bike.

Comments(8)

Jimmy Stewart's Imaginary Rabbit says...
8:50am Tue 16 Oct 12

I like the idea, but despite all the hot air there will never be a protest of the type you describe for the simple reason that we're not French, and being British we prefer to supinely follow every petty rule and regulation

I'm a Fiveways resident and personally we avoid the sky-high in-city bus fares and parking charges by not using either - I do a 'drop off, then pick up later' shuttle service.

Baldseagull says...
10:45am Tue 16 Oct 12

They don't need processing in a day, if everyone pays the fine.
What they would struggle to do is meet the obligation to consider every appeal if 4500 appeals come in over a week or two.
Everyone should appeal ANY parking ticket they get, I have had some appeals granted just on the basis that they were too busy to look into it properly, even though my reasons for appeal were never going to get me anywhere on merit.
And if a local authority reject an appeal without addressing the reasons you raise in appeal, you can appeal against that decision on the grounds that your first appeal had not been considered properly.
There are often very valid reasons that you may not be aware of for appealing, and usually what would be common sense to most of us as fair play is no use at all, go to www.pepipoo.com for advice before paying any parking ticket, in fact go there now so you know what info to gather from the site of the alleged offence, when it happens to you, and it will happen sooner or later.

deanaprior says...
12:07pm Tue 16 Oct 12

Is this gonzo journalism at its finest?

Hove Actually says...
4:32pm Tue 16 Oct 12

The Car hating council rely on our apathy to rake in obscene fines for trivial infringements, i.e overstay 301 seconds on a four hour ticket and thats £70 Thank you very much. A figure more than a days pay for the average worker.

luckily I and most of the people I speak to find travelling out of Brighton is easier, quicker and cheaper for shopping now days.

Four of us travelled to London off peak on Southern Trains for £24 had a fantastic day out a figure not much more than the cost of us travelling into Brighton on the bus from Hove.

People are taking the p1ss and when enough shoppers go elsewhere that's when things will change

NickBtn says...
5:17pm Tue 16 Oct 12

Jimmy Stewart's Imaginary Rabbit wrote:
I like the idea, but despite all the hot air there will never be a protest of the type you describe for the simple reason that we're not French, and being British we prefer to supinely follow every petty rule and regulation

I'm a Fiveways resident and personally we avoid the sky-high in-city bus fares and parking charges by not using either - I do a 'drop off, then pick up later' shuttle service.
The council is hoping that high parking fares will decrease car usage or get us to use the expensive (esp. for single or return journey) buses...

Their hope is that car usage will fall and so too will pollution and congestion

Yet here is another example that car usage has doubled with their parking policies - rather than park shuttling back and forward and then back and forward.

Another own goal for council policy!

Perhaps reasonable parking charge levels and times would help.....

Jimmy Stewart's Imaginary Rabbit says...
8:33am Wed 17 Oct 12

NickBtn wrote:
Jimmy Stewart's Imaginary Rabbit wrote:
I like the idea, but despite all the hot air there will never be a protest of the type you describe for the simple reason that we're not French, and being British we prefer to supinely follow every petty rule and regulation

I'm a Fiveways resident and personally we avoid the sky-high in-city bus fares and parking charges by not using either - I do a 'drop off, then pick up later' shuttle service.
The council is hoping that high parking fares will decrease car usage or get us to use the expensive (esp. for single or return journey) buses...

Their hope is that car usage will fall and so too will pollution and congestion

Yet here is another example that car usage has doubled with their parking policies - rather than park shuttling back and forward and then back and forward.

Another own goal for council policy!

Perhaps reasonable parking charge levels and times would help.....
I can't speak for visitors but for Brighton residents there is a bit of the 'Law of Unintended Consequences' coming into play. For years we always used the bus to get into town, but now it costs the two of us nearly £10 to get from Fiveways to Churchill Square and back. Far too expensive given our somewhat-straightene
d circumstances in this recession. And the high parking prices mean that's a no-no as well. The result? We now make four car journeys when we used to make none! And the weird thing is: reasonable parking charges would see us halve our car use. Speaking to friends and neighbours I know we're not alone both in our views and the way we're working round it.

Mr Sworld says...
1:58am Thu 18 Oct 12

Congratulations!

Would the journalist like a medal? Or should we subsidise his parking ticket fine?

Do you really take your car into town to pick up a paper? Why?

£3.50 would pay for a paperboy or paper girl for the entire week.

Lazy journalism, useless story and poor reporting.

Editor, please sack him.

Pitviper says...
11:12am Fri 2 Nov 12

Baldseagull wrote:
They don't need processing in a day, if everyone pays the fine. What they would struggle to do is meet the obligation to consider every appeal if 4500 appeals come in over a week or two. Everyone should appeal ANY parking ticket they get, I have had some appeals granted just on the basis that they were too busy to look into it properly, even though my reasons for appeal were never going to get me anywhere on merit. And if a local authority reject an appeal without addressing the reasons you raise in appeal, you can appeal against that decision on the grounds that your first appeal had not been considered properly. There are often very valid reasons that you may not be aware of for appealing, and usually what would be common sense to most of us as fair play is no use at all, go to www.pepipoo.com for advice before paying any parking ticket, in fact go there now so you know what info to gather from the site of the alleged offence, when it happens to you, and it will happen sooner or later.
I've had a look at the site and I cannot see what section relates to parking fines, maybe you would care to enlighten me!

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree