Albion got there in the end.
But who did you think did most to see them over the line at Swindon?
Adrian Colunga and Jake Forster-Caskey were major providers to the four-goal tally.
Rohan Ince scored an absolute beauty on the volley.
And Lewis Dunk was excellent at the back, as well as going close to a goal himself.
Albion were caused some problems out wide but their full-backs stuck at it and arguably looked more secure as the tie progressed.
So who impressed you? Cast your vote and add your comment.
- Revell wipes out Albion lead - from the Amex
- Albion v Rotherham - the last word in match previews LIVE from the Amex
- Bennett passed fit - and Ince and Colunga both start too
- Revell leads the attack as Rotherham face Seagulls
- Albion star says blame players, not the boss